Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine

Will the Blue Jays advance to the ALDS this year?

Yes 56 (87.50%)
No 8 (12.50%)
Will the Blue Jays advance to the ALDS this year? | 11 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Alex Obal - Friday, February 22 2013 @ 10:22 PM EST (#268869) #
We'll probably do a more specific win total poll later on, but for now, here's this...
Parker - Saturday, February 23 2013 @ 11:10 AM EST (#268871) #
I had to vote yes. Hope springs eternal.
hypobole - Saturday, February 23 2013 @ 04:50 PM EST (#268876) #
I want to believe they'll make it that far, but I had to do a George Costanza opposite and voted no.
katman - Sunday, February 24 2013 @ 12:41 AM EST (#268881) #
Even with a very good team, if you're betting, the odds almost always favor "no" due to random events.

Meanwhile, we live in hope.
greenfrog - Sunday, February 24 2013 @ 03:53 PM EST (#268888) #
I love what AA has done with the team, and I think they have a solid chance at being in the ALDS this year -- I believe Dickey in particular will really help the team's chances in 2013. Ultimately, however, I voted no. In a nutshell, my concerns are as follows: (1) starting pitching depth (once health risks and uncertainty around Romero's performance is factored in); (2) questions around the #5-9 slots in the lineup (lack of plate discipline). I think that the team left a few positions unaddressed (CF, DH, late-inning relief) - in part for budgetary reasons - and that collectively it carries a fairly high injury risk, both on the pitching and positional player side.

The wild card could be Rogers' willingness to spend at the deadline if the Jays are in contention. I expect the Jays will need to add a key piece or two, and with a depleted farm system, the organization may need to take on salary to acquire the players they need to put them over the top.
Mike Green - Monday, February 25 2013 @ 11:03 AM EST (#268895) #
I voted yes.  They've got a decent chance to win the division.   It's probably about 50-50 that they either win the division or win the wild care game. 
Mike Green - Monday, February 25 2013 @ 11:06 AM EST (#268896) #
"Wild care game" is a pretty good typo.  Playing musical wheelchairs probably would not go over too well...

electric carrot - Monday, February 25 2013 @ 12:49 PM EST (#268899) #
The answer is yes.  This team is dynamite and has no significant weaknesses.  There's a reason Las Vegas has them as the favourite to win the World Series.  Of course, anything can happen, but if luck were balanced evenly among all teams the Jays are the best bet to be in ALDS -- so you got to vote yes till the fates decide the rest.
China fan - Monday, February 25 2013 @ 01:07 PM EST (#268900) #
"....my concerns are as follows: (1) starting pitching depth....."

I suppose you're right to identify Romero and health risks (Johnson, Morrow) as potential problems. But on the other hand, how many other teams will have a replacement as good as Happ waiting in the wings, a short drive away, available for promotion at the first sign of trouble? This alleviates a lot of the depth concern, in my view.
Richard S.S. - Tuesday, February 26 2013 @ 03:32 PM EST (#268917) #

Romero is a good pitcher.   He will figure out how to pitch well enough with his knees.   With Morrow following Dickey, it will make his pitches better.   He might not need to give 110% to be very effective.   Johnson is no longer the Ace of a bad Team.   Where he's situated in the Rotation should make it easier to be a very effective Pitcher.    He might not need to give 110% to be very effective.   That being said Happ starts in AAA.   On almost all Teams he's their 3rd, 4th or 5th Starter.   Lincoln would be a 4th or 5th Starter on close a third of most Teams.   There's a big drop after those two, but we might not need them.

We acquired veteran players (check career stats) Izturis, Reyes, Bonifacio, Cabrera, and DeRosa.  They will have something to say if 5-9 repeat 2012 faults.   With 4 right-hand hitters, 2 left-hand hitters and 2 switch-hitters available, facing 5-9 should no longer be easy.

Rasmus no longers hits 1-4, no longer must be a big bat upon whom everyone relies, no longer must play through injuries.   As a 2nd-year Arb, he's got two years to show what he has before any big decision needs to be made.   Lind hits RHP well, and LHP badly.   Can he improve or does the bench get more ABs when he`s platooned?   Too many Pitchers can pitch late innings before it`s a worry.   Too many have said good relievers are found everywhere and cheaply.

Most midseason trades acquire salary for lesser values so I don`t see that as a problem.  Just wait to see what we need. 

bpoz - Wednesday, February 27 2013 @ 04:56 PM EST (#268951) #
I voted yes. It is accepted that the Jays have improved their 2013 talent level. Credit to AA. Then it should follow I believe/hope that a commitment to this level of payroll will give us a realistically good team every year if age & injury issues are not a big problem.
Will the Blue Jays advance to the ALDS this year? | 11 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.