Regardless of who he's pitching for, Tim Lincecum will ...
| Win 250+ games and end up in the HOF |  6 (3.06%) |
| Start multiple All-Star Games and win at least one Cy Young Award | 95 (48.47%) |
| Be a solid #3 guy and have a nice career | 42 (21.43%) |
| Never live up to all the hype, but do okay | 27 (13.78%) |
| Massively flame out | 3 (1.53%) |
| Injure himself with that contorted delivery and disappear | 14 (7.14%) |
| Other (what?) | 9 (4.59%) |
196 votes | 4 featured comments
I said "other". I don't think he'll win 250. I don't think he'll start multiple all-star games and might not win a Cy Young. I do think, however, that he'll be more than a solid #3 guy with a nice career. I'm sure there are lots of solid #1 or #2 pitchers who don't win 250 games or the Cy Young. Perhaps AJ Burnett is a reasonable comparable (sans surgery, hopefully).
Multiple AS games/A Cy young. I think the guy has the potential to be that good.
You don't have to be a great pitcher to win 250 games, you have to be special, which means you have to have some combination of talent/be on winning teams/health.