This is meant to be a debate, a beer-driven barroom discussion, a starting point for conversation; it’s an old argument, “who are the greatest players in MLB history?” – but here, it’s divided into three sub-arguments:
· Who are the greatest players ever at each position?
· Who are the greatest players of my (your) lifetime at each position?
· Who are the greatest active players at each position?
Note, “my lifetime” began in 1966, so for instance, I could technically slot Sandy Koufax into the LHSP position, but I am roughly defining that column (see table, next page) as “guys I remember." Define that differently for yourself if you like, but post your parameters so we know what they are.)
Now, onward to the projected lineup cards; although this is a matter of opinion, so you can’t technically tell me I’m “wrong” about any of these selections, please do let me know who you think I missed or overrated, or whatever …
Time for a new thread, hey? Let's mix it up a little with a Question of the Day spun from a comment posted in the original "at 3" thread by long-time and valued Bauxite 92-93:
" ... the Jays would look mighty impressive if they could pull off a way to acquire [Zack Greinke] without giving up Snider, Drabek, Marcum, Cecil, Romero, or Morrow.
That list of six names includes no less than (the magic number of) five starting pitchers. So think this through and answer as if we're heading into the 2014 season:
Drabek, Marcum, Cecil, Romero, Morrow
- Is this your '14 Jay rotation?
- If so, in what order are they slotted into, 1-5?
- If not, who's not in the rotational plans any more, and who has stepped up to fill (or take) that spot?
Alex Gonzalez and the Atlanta Braves saved us from the prospect of three sweeps in the first round of the playoffs. It was an improbable win for the Braves in many respects. They were down 4-1 with Brian Wilson, San Francisco's closer, on the mound and Atlanta's offense is one of the weakest in the playoffs. Once the Braves tied it Billy Wagner has to leave with an injury and their fate rests with Kyle Farnsworth on the mound, the Farnsworth who not known as a big game pitcher. That view looked to be confirmed when he hit Freddy Sanchez. The Braves options looked bleaker when Buster Posey was up with the bases loaded and one out. Posey grounded the ball to Troy Glaus, who has not played much third this season, and Glaus passed up on the play at home and went around the horn for an inning ending double play.