Magpie suggested Tony Castillo (as well as Jesse Barfield, Tom Henke, and Paul Molitor). He also thought this might be a worthy thread.
I agree.
My personal nominees, in addition to the above, are Shaun Marcum and Orlando Hudson.
David Wells on the mound, Todd Stottlemyre's sliding technique, Cecil Fielder running in full stride, Ricky Henderson leading off for the '93 Jays, Tony Bautista's batting stance.
Those were all quite "artful" in their own way.
Fernandez making the jump and throw from deep in the hole
Fernandez would never do something as unartisitic as a jump throw. He would be glide into left field and do his underhand flip throw without planting.
Without being facetious I'd like to mention Jose Cruz Jr. in this context. He had effortless speed, a cannon (not Barfield strong, but strong), and his swing was textbook at times. It was like watching Griffey Jr play, but without the results.
Still, in terms of raw talent I would argue that few Blue Jays could ever match what Cruz brought to the table. If you put Molitor's brain or Halladay's work ethic in his body he'd have been a first ballot HOF.
Everything Dave Till said--especially about Ernie Whitt who I recall telling Jerry after one game when his formula worked perfectly for a bottom-nine win, that being on the spot like that was what he lived for.
Also the Reed Johnson 'tripod--adjusting gloves, right leg planted, left leg back out of the box, bat propped on cup Speaking of cups: Dave Steib absent-mindedly bouncing the ball off his cup as the batter stood in. And finally George Bell (pretty much my favorite,) horizontal in the air with the effort of his throw. And George falling to his knees in shallow left in the '85 season clincher.
For Artistic, I loved Jimmy Key on the mound. Jimmy doesn't get enough love.
No swing sweeter than John Olerud's. Imagine if he didn't have that head injury? He could have been a pitcher too!
For artistic merit, putting up the SkyDome in 2 1/2 minutes merits some attention:
I loved watching Molitor, especially in 1993. How did the Jays land him? I can't remember
What I remember was that Molitor, like many others, wanted to win, and decided the Brewers weren't serious about it, and weren't serious enough (financially) to keep him. I recall a report suggesting that the huge FA contract the Brewers had overpaid to Teddy Higuera (who pitched just over 120 innings for the team in the 4 years after the contract) rankled.
I also remember reading an article on Molitor in one of those pre-season magazines leading into the 1994 season. It was one of those pieces describing how good he was and under-appreciated until getting the chance to display his talents in the playoffs.
Specifically, it talked about Beeston & Glllick flying to Milwaukee to entice him, meeting over dinner. The writer claimed they were highly impressed by his throughness in trying to determine if the Jays would be the right fit. How serious they were about winning again, what kind of manager Cito was, etc.
One line stuck with me. Noting that Molitor played 3B for the first time in a few years in the WS, the writer said that Molitor told them he couldn't play third anymore. "He said he couldn't... not that he wouldn't".
If the subject is artistic merit, could memory possibly store a sequence of events more delightful than the image of Pat Borders stuffing a giant wad of chaw in his cheek, like a squirrel storing up for winter, followed by the inevitable mud-coloured expectoration? Thine eyes have seen the glory.