Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine

With only a handful of games remaining, Cito Gaston’s time is almost up as manager of the Toronto Blue Jays. It’s about time that we begin a discussion on who should be the field chief in 2011 and beyond.



The 2010 Toronto Blue Jays club was full of surprises. Perhaps second only to slugger Jose Bautista, was the realization that the club is not that far away from contending. Pre-2010, many publications had Toronto projected as a fifth-place team with a terrible record.

With a club that is quickly positioning itself to contend in the near future, Toronto's field manager will play a key role in 2011. The position will require a person who can keep up that winning atmosphere, while also find a way to utilize the young, in-house-developed talent that will be key for this club to compete in the American League East division.

With current manager Cito Gaston set to step down as manager at the end of the 2010 season, the club is reportedly looking to have a new skipper in place by the conclusion of the World Series.

According to MLB Trade Rumors, the club is interviewing and/or considering a vast number of candidates and options that include former Rockies/Cubs manager Don Baylor, former Jay Juan Samuel, former Expos third baseman Tim Wallach, former D-Backs manager Bob Melvin, and former Indians manager Eric Wedge. To my way of thinking, the decision is an easy one. The perfect man for the job is former Florida Marlins manager Fredi Gonzalez. The 46-year-old Cuban would bring five key traits to the role:

1. He's a players' manager, who earns respect.

Gonzalez has been around the game for a long time, including as a minor league catcher in the Yankees system, as a minor league manager, as a coach with the Braves, and as a big league manager with the Marlins. Born in Cuba, he was raised in Florida. He's known for communicating well with young players, who enjoy playing for him. The club had the lowest payroll in both 2008 and '09 and managed winning seasons. Gonzalez was named the Sporting News Manager of the Year for 2008. His ability to manage and get the best out of young players was clear during his time in Florida.

2. He's not afraid to challenge players.

One of the reasons that Gonzalez (at least reportedly) was let go by Florida was the fact that he clashed with the Face of the Franchise shortstop Hanley Ramirez. Knowing it's easier (and cheaper) to replace the manager, the club let Gonzalez go despite some pretty good results by the manager, who was consistently given a small payroll to work with. Gonzalez is known for having a bit of a football coach mentality.

3. He has an appreciation for advanced statistics, as well as traditional baseball scouting.

Gonzalez is known to poke around websites like www.BaseballAnalysts.com. With a young, smart front office that utilizes traditional scouting and statistical analysis, it makes sense that the field personnel should be comfortable with both, as well.

4. He would bring a Latin influence.

This is important because the club is once again investing a lot of money into the international free agent market, with signings like Adonis Cardona and Gabriel Cenas. The club has also brought in key young players like Yunel Escobar.

5. Gonzalez would seemingly help diversify the offense.

The home run is fun and all, but let's be honest... it's not good baseball. The club has turned into a one-dimensional team. Gaston produced players with good home-run totals but many of the hitters regressed in other offensive areas of the game. Under Gonzalez, the Marlins club had to kick and claw for every win.

The Jays organization must act quickly to secure his services, though, as both the Braves and Cubs are thought to be interested in the former Fish skipper. Other than Gonzalez, my other choices would be Juan Samuel, although he’s mostly unproven as a manager, which could be detrimental to this club, and Eric Wedge, who handled a young roster in Cleveland but had a tendency to favor veteran (bench-worthy) players a little too much at the expense of young, unproven guys. My least favorite candidate at this point would be Baylor, who is similar to Gaston and always managed very one-dimensional, homer-happy clubs. He also had a tendency – in my opinion – to over-use and abuse his pitching staff... especially the bullpen.

So, what do you think?

The Case for Fredi Gonzalez | 11 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
mathesond - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 11:22 AM EDT (#223365) #
I'm sold
85bluejay - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 11:25 AM EDT (#223366) #

I would be shocked if Fredi Gonzalez isn't the next Braves manager, so I think the Jays pursuit would be futile.

Cito Gaston's public support for Don Baylor means that Mr. Baylor will get an interview but almost certainly will

not get the job as I don't think AA or any GM can let it seem as if the previous manager is dictating his replacement

regardless of Mr. Baylor's qualification or lack-thereof.

I've read a lot of posting in support of Brian Butterfield and while  Mr. Butterfield might make a good manager,

I think he would be a disaster for the Jays - he has Jimy Williams written all over him - Excellent longtime 3rd

base coach, very popular with the players -  I believe will have a very difficult time transitioning to the

Manager's role. 

Tim Wallach and Tampa's bench coach Martinez  would be my favourite's

Mike Green - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 11:26 AM EDT (#223367) #
I have no idea whether the names you mentioned are the only ones that are being seriously considered.  Certainly Butterfield's name has been thrown out there.

The development of young players under Gonzalez in Florida has been mixed.  While Ramirez and Josh Johnson have developed, Jeremy Hermida has been a disappointment and Ricky Nolasco has not really taken a step forward.  I don't count this record as a negative; almost every manager has a mixed bag of development "successes" and "failures", which may reflect more on the players involved than the manager's skill.

85bluejay - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 11:30 AM EDT (#223368) #
Just to elaborate - I'm sold on Fredi Gonzalez, but I  think  he's Atlanta bound.
jerjapan - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 11:37 AM EDT (#223370) #
Gonzalez sounds good to me, as does Butter - I'm worried that if he doesn't get the main gig that he's Baltimore-bound, and he's done such good work with our infielders I think that'd be a loss.  Than again, I thought losing Arnsberg would hurt more than it did.

I don't want to see a retread manager like Baylor though ...

Magpie - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 12:03 PM EDT (#223375) #
I also think Gonzalez is likely Atlanta bound. As for Baylor, he's 61 years old and for that reason alone I can't see it happening.

Juan Samuel, who'll be 50 next year, is more interesting. Most guys (but not all) manage the way they played, and Samuel was one of the worst percentage players you'd ever want to see. And that makes him rather like another Dominican who ended up managing and did okay, as fans of the 1994 Expos will tell you.
TamRa - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 12:36 PM EDT (#223380) #
I think you'd get a virtually unanimous vote for Gonzalez, but the handwriting is on that wall, right?

I posted last night - my hunch is that it will be Wallach.


Thomas - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 12:43 PM EDT (#223382) #
Cito Gaston's public support for Don Baylor means that Mr. Baylor will get an interview but almost certainly will not get the job as I don't think AA or any GM can let it seem as if the previous manager is dictating his replacement regardless of Mr. Baylor's qualification or lack-thereof.

I disagree. I think AA would certainly hire Baylor if he was the most qualified person for the job. Cito has never said that Baylor should get the job, only that he should get an interview. He's expressed a similar sentiment about Juan Samuel, too.

I would have no problem with AA interviewing both men and I think Anthopolous would hire Baylor in a second if he was the right guy. I don't think it would be seen as Cito dictating the managerial choice, at all. I don't think either Baylor or Samuel will get the job because, as difficult as it is to evaluate managers from the outside, I don't believe either is the best candidate for the position.

I've read a lot of posting in support of Brian Butterfield and while Mr. Butterfield might make a good manager, I think he would be a disaster for the Jays - he has Jimy Williams written all over him - Excellent longtime 3rd base coach, very popular with the players - I believe will have a very difficult time transitioning to the Manager's role.

Why would a longtime coach who is popular with the players have difficulty transition into the manager's role? Didn't the Jays have a hitting coach in the late 1980's who was popular with the players and transitioned into the manager's role to great success?

John Northey - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 05:12 PM EDT (#223398) #
Having serious enough issues with a young star on your team that you get fired mid-season is a pretty big deal and if I was AA I'd be wanting to know why it got so out of hand to reach that stage. It seems he had an issue with Uggla the year before as well (he left a game early with a strained hamstring) based on what I'm finding.

How you deal with stars is vital. Sometimes you have to do a Billy Martin/Reggie Jackson mess to get where you want to go (see NYY in the 70's) but it cannot hit the stage where it negatively affects overall results.
Magpie - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 06:13 PM EDT (#223401) #
Excellent longtime 3rd base coach, very popular with the players

That also describes Ron Gardenhire. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. Three different teams rolled the dice with Jimy Williams.
scottt - Friday, October 01 2010 @ 08:09 PM EDT (#223403) #
Is Gardenhire a great coach or just lucky to be managing a team with a few great players. I've seen the Twins play some terrible ball against the Jays more than once.
The Case for Fredi Gonzalez | 11 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.