Well, uh, a couple of days ago. Still, better late than never. We'll take a look at the two sides.
American League
Starters (Pos/Name/Team/Appearance)
Reserves
Pitchers
National League
Starters (Pos/Name/Team/Appearance)
Reserves
Pitchers
Preliminary thoughts from this corner: it's tough to get too worked up about any of this stuff, really. Scott Rolen should have made the team ahead of Micheal Young - there's really no rational explanation as to why he didn't. Marco Scutaro would have been a nice choice, but has fallen off somwhat dramatically in the last month or so, and isn't really anyone's definition of a star. Adam Lind would have been a fine choice in an AL park year, but these things sometimes work out like this. Tim Wakefield probably isn't that deserving, nor is Pedroia over Kinsler or Hill. The East is pretty heavily represented, with 16/33 players. In the Senior Circuity, Ryan Howard's inclusion sticks out a bit, as does Pabo Sandoval's exclusion. Jason Marquis is their version of Tim Wakefield, but with better (if not flukier) numbers.
So... worst inclusion? Best? How badly were the Blue Jays screwed over? Your thoughts?
American League
Starters (Pos/Name/Team/Appearance)
C | Joe Mauer | Minnesota | 3 |
1B | Mark Teixeira | NY Yankees | 2 |
2B | Dustin Pedroia | Boston | 2 |
3B | Evan Longoria | Tampa Bay | 2 |
SS | Derek Jeter | NY Yankees | 10 |
OF | Jason Bay | Boston | 3 |
OF | Ichiro Suzuki | Seattle | 9 |
OF | Josh Hamilton | Texas | 2 |
Reserves
C | Victor Martinez | Cleveland | 3 |
1B | Justin Morneau | Minnesota | 3 |
1B | Kevin Youkilis | Boston | 2 |
2B | Aaron Hill | Toronto | 1 |
SS | Jason Bartlett | Tampa Bay | 1 |
3B | Michael Young | Texas | 6 |
OF | Carl Crawford | Tampa Bay | 3 |
OF | Curtis Granderson | Detroit | 1 |
OF | Torii Hunter | LA Angels | 3 |
OF | Adam Jones | Baltimore | 1 |
OF/IF | Ben Zobrist | Tampa Bay | 1 |
Pitchers
RHP | Andrew Bailey | Oakland | 1 |
RHP | Josh Beckett | Boston | 2 |
LHP | Mark Buehrle | Chicago | 4 |
RHP | Zack Greinke | Kansas City | 1 |
LHP | Brian Fuentes | LA Angels | 4 |
RHP | Roy Halladay | Toronto | 6 |
RHP | Felix Hernandez | Seattle | 1 |
RHP | Edwin Jackson | Detroit | 1 |
RHP | Joe Nathan | Minnesota | 4 |
RHP | Jonathan Papelbon | Boston | 4 |
RHP | Mariano Rivera | NY Yankees | 10 |
RHP | Justin Verlander | Detroit | 2 |
RHP | Tim Wakefield | Boston | 1 |
National League
Starters (Pos/Name/Team/Appearance)
C | Yadier Molina | St. Louis | 1 |
1B | Albert Pujols | St. Louis | 8 |
2B | Chase Utley | Philadelphia | 4 |
3B | David Wright | NY Mets | 4 |
SS | Hanley Ramirez | Florida | 2 |
OF | Ryan Braun | Milwaukee | 2 |
OF | Raul Ibanez | Philadelphia | 1 |
OF | Carlos Beltran | NY Mets | 5 |
Reserves
C | Brian McCann | Atlanta | 4 |
1B | Prince Fielder | Milwaukee | 2 |
1B | Adrian Gonzalez | San Diego | 2 |
1B | Ryan Howard | Philadelphia | 2 |
2B | Orlando Hudson | LA Dodgers | 2 |
2B | Freddy Sanchez | Pittsburgh | 3 |
SS | Miguel Tejada | Houston | 6 |
3B | Ryan Zimmerman | Washington | 1 |
OF | Brad Hawpe | Colorado | 1 |
OF | Hunter Pence | Houston | 1 |
OF | Justin Upton | Arizona | 1 |
Pitchers
RHP | Heath Bell | San Diego | 1 |
RHP | Chad Billingsley | LA Dodgers | 1 |
RHP | Jonathan Broxton | LA Dodgers | 1 |
RHP | Matt Cain | San Francisco | 1 |
RHP | Francisco Cordero | Cincinnati | 3 |
RHP | Ryan Franklin | St. Louis | 1 |
RHP | Dan Haren | Arizona | 1 |
RHP | Josh Johnson | Florida | 1 |
LHP | Ted Lilly | Chicago | 2 |
RHP | Tim Lincecum | San Francisco | 2 |
RHP | Jason Marquis | Colorado | 2 |
RHP | Francisco Rodriguez | NY Mets | 4 |
LHP | Johan Santana | NY Mets | 4 |
Preliminary thoughts from this corner: it's tough to get too worked up about any of this stuff, really. Scott Rolen should have made the team ahead of Micheal Young - there's really no rational explanation as to why he didn't. Marco Scutaro would have been a nice choice, but has fallen off somwhat dramatically in the last month or so, and isn't really anyone's definition of a star. Adam Lind would have been a fine choice in an AL park year, but these things sometimes work out like this. Tim Wakefield probably isn't that deserving, nor is Pedroia over Kinsler or Hill. The East is pretty heavily represented, with 16/33 players. In the Senior Circuity, Ryan Howard's inclusion sticks out a bit, as does Pabo Sandoval's exclusion. Jason Marquis is their version of Tim Wakefield, but with better (if not flukier) numbers.
So... worst inclusion? Best? How badly were the Blue Jays screwed over? Your thoughts?