Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
The minor league season opened with a bang on Thursday as the Syracuse Chiefs became the first club in the minors to take the field, as they faced the Cincinnati Reds' Triple-A affiliate, the Louisville Bats. The Chiefs also played the game on grass, after the old turf was removed from the stadium in the off-season.


Syracuse 2 Louisville 0

We all know how much Baseball America loves Jay Bruce and Homer Bailey, as the publication considers Bruce the best prospect in baseball and Bailey found his way onto the Top 100 prospects in baseball list at No. 9. And, well, BA doesn't like our favourite organization as much... although Travis Snider did make it onto the list at No. 11.

On this day, however, the Jays - thanks to left-hander David Purcey - were king. Purcey held the Bats' batters to two hits over six innings of work. He walked two and struck out seven, including Bruce twice. The Chiefs hurler threw 90 pitches, including 57 for strikes. Of the 11 outs he recorded in the field, though, nine were via the flyball... including two that were caught up against the wall by centre fielder Wayne Lydon. It remains to be seen whether his high-fastball/flyball approach will work in the majors. Purcey also started off extremely well the last two seasons before wilting after four or five starts.

Following Purcey from the pen were two fellow left-handers in Bill Murphy, obtained near the end of spring from the Arizona organization, and Mike Gosling, who was obtained in the off-season from the Reds organization. Murphy struck out two during an inning of work and Gosling struck out one during his inning-plus of work. After Gosling allowed a hit to start the ninth inning, former Rays reliever Shawn Camp entered the game, struck out a batter and recored the save for Purcey's first win of the season.

On the offensive side of things, left-fielder Adam Lind scored the game-winning run with his fourth-inning homer. Jorge Velandia, signed as a free agent just before camp broke, scored an insurance run in the eighth inning. After hitting a triple, the diminutive veteran Triple-A shortstop scored on second baseman Joe Inglett's RBI double.

Catcher Robinzon Diaz went 2-for-3 and had two broken-bat singles against Reds starter Bailey. Both Inglett and Velandia also had two hits on the day for the Chiefs. Right-fielder Russ Adams, hitting clean-up, went 0-for-3. First baseman Curtis Thigpen went 0-for-4 and looked a little jumpy, connecting on the first pitch in his first two at-bats (the second time resulted in a double play with two on and one out). Sergio Santos, who is getting accustomed to his new home at third base, went 0-for-3 with a strikeout.

Bailey went seven innings for the Reds and allowed five hits and one run. He walked one and struck out two to take the loss. Former National and Red Gary Majewski was on the mound for the second Chiefs run. Bruce finished 1-for-4 with two strikeouts. Veteran catcher Ryan Hanigan had two hits for the Bats and both came against Purcey. Former Yankee Andy Phillips went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts.


Connecticut 3 New Hampshire 2

The New Hampshire Fisher Cats lost the first game of the season but it was a battle won for Canada as Scott Richmond and A.J. Wideman, both from the Great White North, pitched well. Richmond, signed out of independent baseball in the off-season, went five innings and allowed only three hits and walked one. He also struck out six batters. Unfortunately one of the hits he allowed was a two-run homer to catcher Adam Witter. Wideman went two innings and allowed just one hit, while striking out one. Brazilian southpaw Jo Matumoto worked the final scoreless inning. Both Richmond and Matumoto picked runners off first.

Connecticut starter Adam Cowart wasn't sharp but he was effective as he went 4.1innings and allowed only two runs (one earned) on six hits. He didn't walk a batter and struck out one. Four relievers combined to keep the Fisher Cats off the board.

Offensively, the Fisher Cats out-hit Connecticut nine to four but could not find the winning formula. Lead-off hitter Aaron Mathews went 2-for-5 and scored one run. Catcher Brian Jeroloman, batting second, went 1-for-5 and drove in a run but did not walk (gasp). He also threw out one runner trying to steal a base (while also allowing one stolen base). Shortstop Ryan Klosterman is looking to improve upon a disappointing 2007 in New Hampshire and went 2-for-3, with a run scored and a stolen base. Second baseman Scott Campbell, a New Zealand native who skipped over Lansing to play in Dunedin in 2008, went 2-for-4, while batting ninth.

Outfielder Ryan Patterson had a rough night and went 0-for-4 with four strikeouts. Fellow outfielder Jacob Butler also went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts.


Dunedin2 Cleawater 1

Dunedin started out in a winning way on Thursday despite striding to the plate in the first inning to find rehabbing MLB reliever Brad Lidge on the mound. Lidge actually allowed a home run to centre fielder Sean Shoffit during his lone inning of work. He allowed two hits, one walk and struck out two. 2007 first round draft pick Joe Savery then took the mound for Clearwater and went five innings and allowed no runs. The Jays mustered three hits and five walks against the former top college pitcher, but he also struck out seven. Three other relievers worked for the Thrashers and Andy Cruse allowed the winning run to cross the plate in the seventh inning.

Top prospect Adrian Cardenas went 3-for-4 with two doubles. Third baseman Welinson Baez went 0-for-2 but drove in the lone run.

Jays right-hander Adrian Martin received the start for Dunedin and he went four innings and allowed only one run on seven hits. He struck out two and did not walk a batter. Former independent league hurler Chad Blackwell went two innings and allowed one hit for the win. Edward Rodriguez worked two innings for a hold and struck out three. Converted starter Zach Dials used his sinker/slider combination to secure the save.

Offensively for the Jays, Dunedin returnee Cory Patton went 2-for-4 with two doubles, a walk and a strikeout. First baseman Brian Dopirak, a former Cubs top prospect who hit 39 homers in the Midwest League in 2004, hit the game-winning homer in the seventh inning. He also walked and struck out twice. Brad Emaus, a 2007 draft pick who jumped over Lansing after a hot 2007 playoff run for Auburn, went 1-for-4 with a double and a stolen base. Travis Snider, nursing a sore elbow, pinch hit and walked. He then stole second base, showing there is nothing wrong with his legs. Catcher J.P. Arencibia went 0-for-4 with a walk and two strikeouts.


Fort Wayne 7 Lansing 1

Most Jays fans were thrilled when they saw the organization break away from its college-centric drafting in 2007. The downside to signing a lot of high school players is that they are often very raw and very inconsistent. Such was opening night in the Midwest League as the Lugnuts traveled down to Fort Wayne.

Unlike in previous years, the Lugnuts were the younger of the two squads and the team is a full year younger than the league average age of 22.5. The Wizard's starting pitcher, 22-year-old right-hander Jeremy Hefner, held the Lugnuts to only three hits over five innings. He walked no one and struck out five. Allen Harrington, 21, pitched the final four innings for the save and struck out six, walked one and allowed one run.

Drew Cumberland, a 2007 supplemental first round pick of the Padres, went 2-for-5. Lance Zawadzki, a fourth round pick, went 2-for-4 with a walk. He also scored once and tacked on an RBI.

For the Lugnuts, Canadian right-hander Trystan Magnuson made his pro debut and was noticeably wild during his 1.2 innings of work. He gave up two hits and two walks while allowing three runs (two earned). The first run he allowed was a first-inning homer to designated hitter Angel Mercado. After reaching his pitch limit, Magnuson was replaced by Chi-Hung Cheng, who is playing in Lansing for the third time as he returns from surgery in 2006. The Lugnuts have eight starting pitchers in 2008 and are piggy backing them in games, which is becoming more popular in the low minors.

Cheng pitched 3.1 innings and wasn't sharp. He allowed six hits and four runs. He walked two and struck out just one. Radio announcer and public relations guru Brad Tillery stated that Cheng's velocity is returning well from surgery but he threw only a couple curve balls, which have been his signature pitch in recent years.

Randy Boone was the next arm out of the pen and he was also making his pro debut after sitting out the 2007 while in contract negotiations. He will also be a piggy back starter, but was getting some side work, according to Tillery. Boone pitched one inning and allowed two hits. Left-hander Luis Perez was another tandem starter that got his side work in during a game situation. He pitched one inning and struggled with his control, which was also a problem in spring training. He walked two and allowed one hit, but did not let a run score. Another southpaw, Edgar Estanga, finished out the game with a hitless inning and struck out one.

Justin Jackson, a 2007 second round pick out of high school, went 3-for-4, although one hit could have gone for an error. He also scored the Lugnuts' lone run in the eighth inning. Centre fielder Darin Mastroianni, a converted second baseman, went 2-for-4 with a double and an RBI. 2007 first round pick Kevin Ahrens had the club's only other hit and also struck out once.

Wes Stone, a former high school draft pick, went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts, while first baseman Michael McDade, a converted prep catcher, went 0-for-4 with three Ks. Outfielder Yohermyn Chavez went 0-for-2 but walked twice.

The club made some minor roster moves before finalizing everything by the 4 p.m. deadline. Catcher Matt Liuzza went up to Dunedin to fill in for David Corrente, who has a sore elbow. Catcher Joel Collins, a Canadian and also a Mike Green favourite, was added from extended spring training. Outfielder Victor Santana, who originally made the roster, was released.

Three Stars:
1. David Purcey, for dominating top prospect Jay Bruce and securing the win
2. Justin Jackson, for a 3-for-4 night
3. Brian Dopirak, who hit a game-winning homer playing in his hometown of Dunedin

Shameless Plug:
And if you haven't already checked out Behind the Dish, the free, weekly digital magazine devoted to the Jays minor league system, do so now. The first issue features an in-depth interview with Toronto hurler Jesse Litsch. The second issue, available Tuesday, will have an interview with New Hampshire pitcher (and Canadian) A.J. Wideman.
Take That Baseball America | 22 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Gerry - Thursday, April 03 2008 @ 11:02 PM EDT (#182074) #

Welcome to the Batters Box minor league team Marc and you have made an excellent start. 

We shouldn't read much into a sample size of one game but the Purcey start didn't prove much to me.  He obviously had good results but were those results due to luck or great pitching?  Purcey threw 90 pitches in 6 innings, that is 15 per inning.  Purcey, in the past, has had trouble working deep into games due to his high pitch counts, aka poor control.  Today he threw 60% strikes with these 15 pitches per inning and to me that is average for AAA.  I am looking for Purcey to get to 12-13 pitches per inning, pitch 8 innings consistently, and throw 66% strikes for a few starts in a row and then I will believe he is progressing towards the majors.

And nice start Justin Jackson.

jgadfly - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 12:15 AM EDT (#182075) #

RE: Purcey... of the 9 flyouts, 3 were popouts (2 in foul territory), 1 was a linedrive that Purcey knocked down and threw to first ...9 mph wind blowing out to centre... 2 groundball outs, 1 gb hit up the middle... 1 linedrive hit & 1 ld out both to right fielder Russ Adams...

Thanks Marc, great start... also great site. Congrats !

timpinder - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 01:11 AM EDT (#182076) #

With the return of the minor league reports, baseball is truely back.  Thanks.

Another thing about Purcey is that he has teased before with torrid starts before coming back down to earth.  But this past year was different in that the control was finally there.  He had a 2.32 BB9 rate last year, while his minor league BB9 rate averaged around 5.00 before 2007.  I hope he's 2008's version of McGowan, the high-ceiling guy who finally puts it together, because it's very unlikely that the Jays' rotation will remain intact and injury free all season, and Purcey is likely to be the guy to get the call.

I've got a good feeling about him.  The control is there, more or less, and we knew the stuff was there.

#2JBrumfield - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 02:12 AM EDT (#182077) #

Marc is now the Johnny Cueto of the Minor League Reports.  A very nice debut!  You established the inside part of the plate with some chin music to Baseball America and continued to bring the heat, mixing your plus-plus fastball and breaking pitches with command and location.   A five tool effort for sure.  A 100 on the 20-80 scouting scale.

I'm pleased former Edmonton Cracker-Cat Scott Richmond is off to an encouraging start with New Hampshire.  I thought he was going to start the year in Dunedin but starting in AA makes sense as the Northern League is considered A to AA level baseball.   He did remind me a bit of Roy Halladay in terms of his build (6-6, 215) when I saw him pitch at Telus Field last summer.  He was one of the bright spots in what was a godawful season for the C-Cats.  For me, he'll be "one to watch" over the course of the summer.

Lugnut Fan - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 07:23 AM EDT (#182078) #
I'm very interested to see how Dopirak does in Dunedin.  He  was definitely worth a flyer once the Cubs released him.  If he can return close to his 2003 form where he hit 39 home runs here in Lansing, he could move quickly.  The only problem with him is that he is terrible defensively.
Sister - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 08:42 AM EDT (#182079) #

Does anyone know where OF Eric Eiland is going to play? I have scanned the minor league rosters to no avail. Could he be staying down south until joining Auburn for the short-season?
Mike Green - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 08:49 AM EDT (#182080) #
Nicely done indeed, Marc. 

I am delighted that Collins was added to the Lansing roster, for two reasons.  It makes it more likely that he will get a regular turn behind the plate, and it means that BB will have the benefit of Lugnut Fan's very helpful first-hand reports, instead of my shameless plugging for a favourite.

I am not as worried as Gerry about Purcey's pitches/inning.  Strikeout pitchers do throw more pitches, and can be successful doing it.  Take Erik Bedard. He came up in 2004 at age 25, and was averaging 100 pitches per start (and continues to do so).  His average start was under 6 innings until 2007.  In 2007, he threw 105 pitches and 6.5 innings per start.  The reason for his relatively high pitch count was simply more pitches per PA than the average pitcher (4.0-4.1 on average). 

Purcey did start out like a house on fire in double A in 2007, and then cooled off apparently as a result of an injury.  I expect that he will get the call to the majors at some point in 2008, and it would probably be best to start him in the bullpen.  There's nothing wrong with a pen with four lefties (Purcey, Tallet, Downs, Ryan) when you have an all-righty rotation. 

Marc Hulet - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 09:22 AM EDT (#182084) #
Thank you for the favourable responses... After kicking around here for about five years, I figured it was about time to start earning my keep.

Dick Scott told me that Eiland just missed making the Lansing squad and that he just needs to get his work in down in extended spring training. 

Eiland was the rawest of the high school players taken at the top of the draft... because he was also a top football recruit. He'll likely begin the year at Auburn, although he could slip into Lansing at some point, should an injury occur.

Gerry - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 10:05 AM EDT (#182086) #

Today's starting pitchers:

Syracuse - Josh Banks

New Hampshire - Ricky Romero

Dunedin - Unknown

Lansing - Kyle Ginley

timpinder - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 11:13 AM EDT (#182089) #

I was reading through some scouting reports on Purcey over the years.  When he was drafted he was considered to be an over-draft by Ricciardi and was described as a "one pitch" hurler.  That pitch being the already "plus" 91-95 MPH fastball.  The Jays felt they could improve his curveball and get him to throw a changeup.  Through the years he's progressed, and the most recent scouting reports I've found describe him as still having the great fastball, but he's also developed the curveball into a pitch described as "excellent", "out pitch", and "plus".  The most optimistic reports, however, still have his changeup as "average", at best.

Perhaps he is more suited to the bullpen afterall, at least until he further develops his changeup.  Then again, he's a big imposing lefty and if the stuff is good enough, a starter can still do fine with basically two pitches (see Burnett).

timpinder - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 11:20 AM EDT (#182090) #
I'm looking forward to seeing how Romero does tonight.  I'm hoping for a big year from him.  I know he's being talked about as a bust because of his injury plagued and unsuccessful year last year, but I also read a dozen or so scouting reports on him last night while perusing the web.  Based on his stuff and the fact that he's a lefty, he could easily be a long-term #3 starter in the majors, according to most talent evaluators.  Average fastball but with plus command, and every scouting report I found, even the most recent ones, have him with an excellent or plus curveball and excellent or plus changeup.  He just needs to trust his fastball and work off of it, and stop nibbling (likely why his BB9 rate went up last year).  Between Purcey and Romero, I'm optimistic about the Jays' rotation as early as June, should an injury occur.
FisherCat - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 11:57 AM EDT (#182094) #

Obviously JP's fate (and Gibby's as well) could be sealed with a less than stellar 2008 season, but I also think JP's reputation takes a hit if both Romero and Purcey are busts!  Irregardless of how well the parent club performs.

JP's main selling point to Uncle Ted was to build a fiscally responsible team thru building up the farm team and that college pitchers would become servicable major leaguers SOONER than high-ceiling high schoolers.  Obviously injuries can never be anticipated, but one of these 2 guys SHOULD'VE been battling for a rotation spot this spring.  If the one of these guys cannot become the Jesse Litsch of 2008, then I think JP can kiss his next contract extension goodbye!

Fully anticipating that AJ opts out if he gets 26+ starts this year, and the high prices for #2/#3 starters.  I firmly believe that JP is hinging on slipping one of these guys into the rotation next year instead of BUYING AJ's replacement!

ChicagoJaysFan - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 12:36 PM EDT (#182098) #
JP's main selling point to Uncle Ted was to build a fiscally responsible team thru building up the farm team and that college pitchers would become servicable major leaguers SOONER than high-ceiling high schoolers.  Obviously injuries can never be anticipated, but one of these 2 guys SHOULD'VE been battling for a rotation spot this spring.

I don't want to actually defend JP's draft record, but I think this completely is unfair.  He did put Janssen, Litsch, Mastny, Marcum, and Bush as full-timers in the majors, so it's not like he hasn't put a decent number of arms in the majors from those drafts so far.  Quick trips for Jackson, Peterson, Vermileya, and others as well.  To say it fails because of 2 players I think is a stretch.

I am also not surprised if fans see this year as a make-or-break year for JP, but I don't see it quite in the same light.  At the end of this year, and every year, I want the choice of GM to be based on who is best suited for this team going forward - not on how well they've done in the past.  Especially when hiring a first-time GM, I think you have to look at have they evolved (comparing the '06 and '07 drafts to the earlier ones, it's clear that JP has) and are there others out there that could help the team (there may be, I don't know who is available).  What I'm saying is that Snider and Cecil both seem to be arguably two of the best picks in each of their respective drafts, so it seems like JP is on a roll right now in that area.  (I'm not saying they are each the best prospect, but they are each arguably the best prospect / draft position ratio)

What I don't think is a good way to make a decision is to fire someone because of choices they made in their first 2 or 3 years on the job (Russ Adams, Ricky Romero) - at least when you hired a rookie.  Had we brought in some one established, like Dombrowski, then I think you should expect fewer growing pains and the overall record is probably more applicable.

Also - as to the comment about JP's selling point to Ted Rogers - you are making a bit of a leap that isn't necessarily accurate (or inaccurate).  What you describe is how Ted Rogers sold JP to Jays fans.

Maybe JP's selling point to Ted was, "I'll gut this team and make it fiscally responsible - we'll have to draft a bunch of guys that can get to the majors quickly so the average fan can notice some progress and we can re-build interest while cutting costs.  Then as we build back some interest and our own guys start to come up, we'll start to draft guys with lengthier development processes, etc."  Ted could quite have easily responded, "I hear what you're saying and I like it - this is how I'll sell it to the fans"

I'm not saying that's it - but I think you have to be very careful taking what any GM / owner says in public at face value.
Shane - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 12:56 PM EDT (#182103) #

"What I don't think is a good way to make a decision is to fire someone because of choices they made in their first 2 or 3 years on the job (Russ Adams, Ricky Romero) - at least when you hired a rookie."

GIve me a break! He was a professional scout, talent evaluation is what he got paid for for fifteen years. It's what got him the the interview for the job. This might have flew it you were talking about Paul DePodesta. Ricciardi might be an above average GM if he would just leave the drafting to others perhaps. Tony LaCava or even Tim Wilken maybe. Sheesh.

MatO - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 12:57 PM EDT (#182104) #
Syracuse's game has been postponed.
ChicagoJaysFan - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 01:03 PM EDT (#182105) #
GIve me a break! He was a professional scout, talent evaluation is what he got paid for for fifteen years. It's what got him the the interview for the job. This might have flew it you were talking about Paul DePodesta. Ricciardi might be an above average GM if he would just leave the drafting to others perhaps. Tony LaCava or even Tim Wilken maybe. Sheesh.

I'm not sure if you read the entirety of what I posted or saw the comment "fire someone because of choices they made in their first 2 or 3 years on the job" and then immediately responded.  However, I believe I essentially responded to that when I said ...

Especially when hiring a first-time GM, I think you have to look at have they evolved (comparing the '06 and '07 drafts to the earlier ones, it's clear that JP has)

Firing someone based on actions they took 5 years ago is ridiculous.  Fire JP because you don't like who he drafted last year or this year, fire JP because you don't like the big contracts he's given out, or fire JP because you don't like the direction his last few trades have taken the team.  But do it based on what he's doing now.

Firing him because he made mistakes 5 years ago?  To quote you ... give me a break!
Brian B. - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 01:08 PM EDT (#182107) #
Does anybody have any idea what happened to Marc Rzepczynski?
Gerry - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 01:14 PM EDT (#182108) #
Rzepczynski broke a finger before spring training, should be back soon.  Dick Scott confirmed this to Marc Hulet in an interview to be published next week.
FisherCat - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 01:41 PM EDT (#182109) #

I'm obviously not advising that we "fire" JP based on his picks 5 yrs ago, but unfortunately I think that since he came in with the background he had, drafting was expected to be a strong suit. 

That being said; if Russ Adams had the success that Aaron Hill has had so far, I think we'd all be singing a different tune.  But because his first ever pick as our GM has been an absolute failure, he'll never get a break when it comes to draft picks.

I am glad to see that their philosophy has changed w/r/t early round picks (high school vs college)

ChicagoJaysFan - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 02:03 PM EDT (#182111) #
I'm obviously not advising that we "fire" JP based on his picks 5 yrs ago, but unfortunately I think that since he came in with the background he had, drafting was expected to be a strong suit.


I'm not sure that I understand your disagreement with my original comment then.
FisherCat - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 02:15 PM EDT (#182112) #

I think the point I'm trying to make is that even if the Jays win 87-90 games this year, but still finish 7 or 8 games out of a playoff spot AND then Purcey or Romero still aren't making significant contributions b4 opening day next year then we won't see him return for 2009.

I understand that some of JP's picks have become servicable major leaguers, as you pointed out., but as a whole there hasn't been a stud among them.  Plus, with Snider injured and DH'ing in HI-A he's no closer than Sept '09 at the earliest.  Which will be too late to save JP.

ChicagoJaysFan - Friday, April 04 2008 @ 03:18 PM EDT (#182117) #

I think the point I'm trying to make is that even if the Jays win 87-90 games this year, but still finish 7 or 8 games out of a playoff spot AND then Purcey or Romero still aren't making significant contributions b4 opening day next year then we won't see him return for 2009.

I understand that some of JP's picks have become servicable major leaguers, as you pointed out., but as a whole there hasn't been a stud among them.  Plus, with Snider injured and DH'ing in HI-A he's no closer than Sept '09 at the earliest.  Which will be too late to save JP.


I'm not sure if this is what you think will happen or what you think should happen, but I disagree with the decision making process on both fronts.

What I think will happen is that JP's return in 2009 will depend entirely on ticket sales for this year.  If the Jays' attendance doesn't drop significantly, he'll be back.

If your comment referred to how the decision should be made - I think I've covered it earlier, so I won't rehash it hear.  However, what I don't understand with your statement is that while you said earlier you don't think JP should be fired based on his drafting of 4-5 years ago, the above statement seems to contradict this comment.  Here, you're tying his retention to the Romero pick.  And you place a much greater weight on Romero's success than Snider's, even though Snider is the more recent draft pick and thus more reflective of JP's current drafting style / skill.
Take That Baseball America | 22 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.