Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
Maybe the Wild Card will be coming from the AL East after all...

The White Sox came out of the All-Star break and obligingly lost 10 of 12 games, getting swept by the Yankees and Twins, and losing two of three from both Detroit and Texas. The previously unbeatable Jose Contreras lost three consecutive starts. Mark Buehrle, who for the last several years has been one of the best and most dependable pitchers in all of baseball, has suddenly turned into... Josh Towers? Since July 1, Buehrle is 0-5, 11.48. He's allowed 47 hits and 8 HR in just 26.2 innings.

Who's stepping up to take advantage of this unexpected opportunity? Who the hell do ya think?

Chien Ming-Wang pitched a two-hit shutout yesterday, improving his record to 12-4. Despite striking out just 45 guys in148 innings. The chances are remote that Wang can have a long and prosperous career with so few strikeouts - you have to go back at least 50 years to find a starting pitcher who was successful more than a year or two with such an approach - but it's working right now, which is all that really matters for 2006. The Bombers' only recent blip came when they dropped three of four on their most recent visit to the RC. Aside from that little misadventure, they've won 13 of their last 15. They've taken over the lead in the Wild Card, and they're just half a game back of the Red Sox for first place in the division.

And Gary Sheffield has just had the cast removed from his hand. Hideki Matsui, who ha been at the park every day working on his recovery, is hitting off a tee.

Still... no one is surprised that the Yankees are once more in the thick of things. They paid good money to be there, lots and lots of it. The surprises... those would be the Tigers and the Twins, right? The amazing Florida Marlins (37-22 since May 22? Who are these guys?)

So, Bauxites.... let's have some nominations. Biggest surprises of the year, teams and players. Biggest disappointments. Let's celebrate the Unexpected and Unforeseen...
TDIB Saturday | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Mike Green - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 03:07 PM EDT (#151774) #
The Marlins definitely surprised me.  If someone had said at the start of the season that the Marlins would be in second place in the NL East on July 29, I would have probably said that it would be a 100-1 shot.

Among the players, Jon Papelbon surprised me.  I figured that he had a good chance to be a fine pitcher, but that he would be better than Mariano Rivera comes as a shock.

CaramonLS - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 03:21 PM EDT (#151775) #
Biggest disappointments:

Phillies:  Billed as a real threat to contend, their pitching has been absolutely brutal and their hitting has been very inconsistant.

Braves:  I thought they were going to keep there winning ways and win the division again, but there is just about no plausable way they can do that.  Especially overcoming all the adversity last season to do it, I thought it was pretty reasonable to expect them to win again.

Angels:  The Pitching has been pretty good, if you ignore the Jeff Weaver experiment, however their offense has been bad.  Just plain bad.  The Young guys like McPherson and Kotchman were supposed to step it up and play pivotal roles for this team, but they have not - both have been injured and even when healthy were plagued with mediocrity. 

Oh, and what is up with that Mike Napoli kid?  With all the talent in the Angels system, you hear nothing of him and he comes up and has been one of their most effective hitters. 

The NL:  Getting steamrolled in interleague play, Only 5/16 teams have records over .500 - Just generally sucking. 

Josh Towers:  No comment needed.

The Surprises:

Mets:  Ok, so you know they were going to be pretty good, at least threaten the Braves for the Division, but I don't think that many people saw them simply breaking away from the Division like they have.   The best team in the NL right now.

Detroit:  So yeah, those guys.. leading the AL, who'd have thunk that.
AWeb - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 03:54 PM EDT (#151776) #
For the Jays, for a good surprise, how about having 5 outfielders (Wells, Rios, Hinske, Johnson, Catalanotto) all having far and away career years so far? Surprises me, at least.

The top 4 in the NL batting race : Freddy Sanchez , Chipper Jones, Scott Hatteburg, Nomar.

Teixeira losing his power has been surprising.

Jermaine Dye, MVP candidate.

Teams : AL must be Detroit, and Cleveland in the other direction. NL teams are all so mediocre...11 teams within 9 games of the wild card, not counting the Padres. Every team except the Cubs and Priates (not surprising) are a 7 game winning streak from being in it, or leading. Collectively, the lack of any teams breaking away from the pack in either direction is surprising.

Mylegacy - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 03:59 PM EDT (#151777) #

The biggest disappointment is Towers TOTAL collapse, still going on at AAA.

The biggest surprise is the scrappy, wonderful play of Cat, Reed and Rios.

The biggest perplexion (is that a word?) has been the slow return to form of McGowan and Rosario and the slow maturation of League.

The biggest surprise to come is the comtribution down the home stretch by McGowan, League, Marcum and Hinske. Yep, you heard right, Hinske.

Joanna - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 04:07 PM EDT (#151778) #

Biggest Disapointment- The Cleaveland Indians.  They seemed very good last year, or at least threatened to be really good.  A guy in my neighbourhood, big Indians fan, has an Indians flag in his backyard that he hangs at half mast if they lose.  It's rarely up the pole. 

Surprise-  The Tigers and The Twins.  I still kinda think of Detroit as being a bad team.  Just a force of habit.  The Twins looked kinda sad at the beginning of the year.  It took them a while to heat up,  their one-two in the pitching department is sick.

 Young pitching has been crazy good. Pabelbon (to Boston fans, he's the Messiah, but to me, he's just a great pitcher).  Jared Weaver has been fantastic.  Liriano is a front runner for the AL Cy Young.

Also, the complete dominance of the AL over the NL (except the Blue Jays).  Now I've always been an AL girl.  To me,  in the offensive innings, the pitcher should be having little discussions with the pitching coach or staring dejectedly into space, not bunting over runners or pathetically striking out.  So I like it when my  league is dominant.

Mick Doherty - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 05:18 PM EDT (#151779) #
In 2005, I wrote a preview that picked the Reds to go to the World Series ... so the biggest surprise last year, to me, was how much the Reds genuinely blew chunks. And in this year's preview, I changed course completely and predicted the Reds would, the exact word I used was, "suck."

As I write this comment, those same Reds are 55-48, a close second in the NL Central and leading the NL Wild Card race. So yeah, color me surprised (again).

From this year's preview: "Call it 64-98, last place, NL Central. And hope last year's reverse-prediction deities are feeling kindly to the Queen City in 2006, of course."

So maybe I got that last line right ...

Gerry - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 05:38 PM EDT (#151780) #
Todays start by Dustin McGowan reminded me of seeing McGowan pitch in Syracuse earlier this season.   My comment in this thread talks about McGowan's tendency to get beaten with his fastball, today's start was another example of that.  The big hits were off that fastball, the encouraging thing is that McGowan has the good stuff, he needs to learn to pitch, not throw.
Craig B - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 09:33 PM EDT (#151786) #
Biggest surprise team - Minnesota.  I figured the Twins for the fourth-best team in the AL Central, and about ninth in the AL.  They started out playing exactly to my expectations and then all of a sudden, all at once, things just started clicking in the brains of people in Minnesota, like they'd spilled some chemical in the water (Batgirl would understand).  Justin Morneau started concentrating on making contact instead of trying to hit everything through the pitcher.  Terry Ryan decided to try out using his best players.  Fransisco Liriano, with the season basically thrown away I might add, was sent from the bullpen to the starting rotation about two years quicker than Johan Santana was.  And three of the five horrible, crappy awful Twins that were on my HACKING MASS team to start the year (because Gardenhire insisted that they would be important cogs for him) were gone.

I thought the Twins were going to remain an exercise in frustration - they didn't, they showed how smart they are (this really is a smart franchise) and have done even more than I thought possible.

I thought that Colorado would be competitive, Florida would survive, and Detroit were a pretty decent team - so I didn't pick any of them.

Biggest surprise, player - Reed Johnson.  Alex Rios has been pleasant, but many of knew he could do it.  Reed Johnson is competing for a freakin' *batting title*. 

Biggest disappointment, team - Atlanta Braves.  Easily.  I know the season isn't over, but the Braves look somnambulent.


Biggest disappointment, player - Rich Harden and Eric Gagne.  My AL and NL Cy Young picks respectively - Harden's missed most of the season and Gagne had back surgery and now I'm wondering if he'll even ever pitch again.  If we eliminate injuries, then no question that (with a nod to Russ Adams, who I had high hopes for) it's Yadier Molina, who needs to find his bat.  Molina's a favorite of mine and seeing him struggle pains me.  Ronny Cedeno gets a nod here too.
Craig B - Saturday, July 29 2006 @ 09:36 PM EDT (#151787) #
Among the players, Jon Papelbon surprised me.  I figured that he had a good chance to be a fine pitcher, but that he would be better than Mariano Rivera comes as a shock.

My prediction for this year that I'm most proud of is Jon Papelbon as my AL Rookie of the Year.
TDIB Saturday | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.