Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
Close your notebooks, everyone. There'll be no lesson, just a snap quiz. You're still at the helm of the Jays for this one.

It's late May, and everything is going pretty much swimmingly. The team sits at 27-18, a game up on the Yankees and Red Sox, as the Yankees come to visit Toronto for the first of a four game weekend set. The Rogers Centre is sold out on a Thursday night as Randy Johnson, eager for revenge for the tough loss you pinned on him a couple of weeks prior, starts for the Yanks against Ted Lilly. You have Burnett (in his fourth start of the season), Halladay and Chacin as your scheduled starters for the remainder of the series.

At 2 p.m, you allow yourself a few minutes to think about the season so far. Everyone has performed about the same as last year, except for Russ Adams, Aaron Hill and Alex Rios who have all made small but noticeable improvements. You had planned to platoon Rios with Eric Hinske, but early on Eric broke a bone in his hand when he was hit by a pitch and was out for six weeks. Hinske returned a week ago, and has made 3 starts (one when Catalanotto was sick six days ago and the other 2 to give Hillenbrand and Rios a rare day off). He seems to have made a complete recovery from his injury. Rios on the other hand took full advantage of his opportunity by hitting well, and perhaps more importantly, has shown signs of maturity by playing hard at all times.

Burnett has had an up and down recovery from his elbow troubles, but threw six solid innings in his last start. Aside from the injuries to Burnett and Hinske, the team has been healthy. You count your blessings and knock on wood.

You then revert to full "game-preparation mode". The lineup is set:

Adams
Johnson
Wells
Glaus
Overbay
Hillenbrand
Molina
Hill
Rios

The bullpen is in pretty good shape for the series. Halladay and Chacin threw rare back-to-back complete games on Monday and Tuesday (the fact that the Royals were the opposition played no role in it, you chuckle to yourself). Yesterday, Josh Towers had his first rough outing. He was gone in the second inning, but Pete Walker came on and carried the team through six. The team made a game of it, and Schoeneweis, Chulk and Frasor each pitched an inning. Scott Downs rejoined the pen after Burnett returned to the rotation, and is well rested.

The game starts and Johnson is unhittable. The Yanks strike first on a 3 run homer by A-Rod in the 4th inning, but Ted Lilly settles in and holds the Yanks to those 3 runs through 8 innings. Johnson has a shutout, but starts to tire in the bottom of the eighth. Molina and Hill take him deep into counts, strike out (that makes 12 for the Unit on the night), but Rios walks and Adams follows it up with a homer to right, and suddenly we have a ballgame. Johnson (Randy) retires Johnson (Reed) and the game moves to the ninth.

You bring on B.J. Ryan (who has not thrown in five days) for the ninth. He retires the bottom of the Yankee order in order, and sets the stage for the bottom of the ninth, with the Jays down 3-2. The Rogers Centre is rocking.

Enter Sandman. Mariano Rivera comes on. Vernon Wells jumps on the first pitch and laces a double over the third base bag. Troy Glaus walks; two on, nobody out and up comes Lyle Overbay. The infield is set at double play depth with Giambi holding on Glaus and A-Rod about even with the bag at third.

Your first question:

Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?


Whatever you chose, the result is the same, the runners advance to second and third and Overbay is out. This leads to our next questions. Hillenbrand's up. Rivera's pitching, 1 out, runners on 2nd and 3rd. You have Catalanotto, Hinske, Zaun and McDonald on your bench.

Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?



Whatever you chose, your team scores a single run off Rivera and the game heads to extras. The water cooler in the Yankee dugout takes blows (with the feet) from Rivera and Johnson. In the tenth, the Yanks have Damon, Jeter and A-Rod up, with Sheffield to follow. Ryan has thrown more than an inning twice  so far this season, each time coming on to successfully retire a left-handed hitter with two out in the eighth and following it up with an uneventful ninth. Your final question is:

Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth?

Do you leave Ryan in there, or call for somebody else? What is your pitching plan for the top of the tenth?



You have 30 seconds to make each of these decisions, and 10 minutes to write each of them up. Good luck!

Next time, we'll see how Bauxites handle National League managing an unfamiliar team.
You Be the Manager-Big Game, Small Ball, Extra Fun | 33 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Jim - TBG - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 08:27 AM EDT (#144586) #

I don't bunt with Overbay. If we were talking about Otis Nixon, maybe, but bunting doesn't seem to be Overbay's strong suit, and who wants a pop out or weak K in this situation? I might even consider pinch hitting with a strong bunter on the bench, but no one on the Jays bench qualifies.

I let Hillenbrand hit with runners on 2nd and 3rd, but I go to Catalanotto with 1st and 2nd. He's the best batting average vs. RH in this group and probably faster than Hillenbrand.

Since Ryan didn't struggle in the 9th, he's back for the 10th. Besides, just TRY taking the ball from him in this situation.

 

zeppelinkm - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 08:47 AM EDT (#144588) #

No bunt from Overbay. He's too good a contact hitter. Chances are he'll advance the runners anyways. Maybe a hit and run would be in order instead of a bunt.

Let Hillenbrand hit. He's a professional hitter and I'd have faith in his ability to hit a sac fly or a single.  I'd still let him hit if it was 1st and 2nd. Maybe start the runners to avoid a double play though, but we're paying him over 5 million bucks a year and its for him to deliver in situations like this.

Ryan starts the 10th. Like Jim said, he had no problems in the 9th. If he had walked a batter and allowed a single, and went deep into the count with a few guys, I'd bring in somebody else, but if he's cruisin, you ride it!

timpinder - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:01 AM EDT (#144590) #

1)  I let Overbay swing away.  I'm guessing he has around a .380 OBP at this point and has been our most consistant hitter, and he doesn't have a lot of experience bunting.  I'd go for the win.

2)  I don't bring in a lefthanded bat to pinch-hit for Shea.  Even though he's a righty, Rivera's cutter is devastating to lefthanders.  I've actually seen switch-hitters turn around to hit righthanded against Rivera.  Shea stays in.

3)  Ryan comes out in the 10th, but only to face Damon.  When the righthanded Jeter comes up, I bring in Chulk. 

rpriske - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:12 AM EDT (#144593) #

All the answers were no: no bunt, no pinch hit, no nothing.

And I keep Ryan in for the tenth. He's a big, strong guy. H eshouldn't fall apart after pitching one inning.

Craig B - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:13 AM EDT (#144594) #

Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

No, since Overbay doesn't bunt.  Not his role on the team.

Hillenbrand's up. Rivera's pitching, 1 out, runners on 2nd and 3rd. You have Catalanotto, Hinske, Zaun and McDonald on your bench.  Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

No, I like Shea in this situation, since he won't get cheated by Rivera and will likely get his bat on something.  I'll probably have the contact play on, with Vernon running on contact, even with the infield in.  We'll very likely get a run if Shea can get something on the ground even against a drawn-in infield; Posada is a p***y and will shy away from contact with a big, strong, fast guy like Vernon.

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?

Shea would still hit.  I'll keep Catalanotto back to hit for Bengie Molina.

In the tenth, the Yanks have Damon, Jeter and A-Rod up, with Sheffield to follow. Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth? What is your pitching plan for the top of the tenth?

BJ is rested.  I'd like to know the pitch count here but he should be at 15 pitches or less if he retired the side in order.  I'll ask him when we score the run how he feels, expect an affirmative response, and when I get it I'll tell him that if we don't score a second run he's going to pitch the tenth.  After the first hitter in the tenth I get Speier and Schoeneweis up to get loose... once Ryan goes over 30 pitches I'll bring Speier in unless there are two out.  If there are two out, Ryan goes over 30 and the next hitter gets on, Justin comes in to close things out.  If it's a lefty other than Matsui, I might play a hunch and go with the SS LOOGY.

If Ryan for some reason says he doesn't feel right when I ask him, I get Speier and Schoeneweis up and Speier pitches the tenth.

Craig B - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:16 AM EDT (#144595) #
Looking back on my answers after writing them up, I only had misgivings about my answer on Shea hitting with runners on first and second.  Shea and Rivera with a runner on first is a recipe for a double play to end the game, and you could legitimately prefer Hinske here as lefthanded and generally less susceptible to the DP... I might second-guess myself on that one after the game, but Shea's a gamer and it would be tough to take him out in the kind of circumstance he thrives on.
Mike Green - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:33 AM EDT (#144600) #

There are obviously other factors, but the 3 year splits each has against right-handed pitchers are:

  • Hillenbrand .285/.329/.438
  • Cat              .310/.368/.464
  • Hinske         .253/.334/.416
SimonB - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:51 AM EDT (#144605) #
I'm going to go against the grain. Bunt from Overbay! I don't care if he's a great contact hitter, leaving him up there to swing away - aginst Mo of all people - is a recipe for a K or a DP. With runners at 2nd and 3rd and 1 out, the batter behind Overbay merely has to make contact (and not pop it up) for the game to be tied. It's the bottom of the ninth; play for the tie at home, the win on the road. Especially against a pen like the Yankees; you're not going to score twice against Rivera - try to scrape out the tie and go against their weaker pitchers for the victory.

Letting Overbay swing away in that spot makes absolutely no sense to me. Even as averse as the Jays are to bunting, I think it would be a huge mistake.

I also probably pinch-hit Cat; he is a professional contact/line-drive hitter in a situation that calls for absolutely any kind of contact. The one thing to give me pause is the toughness of Rivera's cutter against lefties. Regardless, I trust Cat to make some contact.

I'm tempted to leave Ryan out there in the 10th, although it depends how effective he's been vs lefties and vs righties all year, as well as how good the rest of the pen has been.

Craig B - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 09:59 AM EDT (#144608) #

Letting Overbay swing away in that spot makes absolutely no sense to me. Even as averse as the Jays are to bunting, I think it would be a huge mistake.

Except that Overbay doesn't bunt.  Ever.  Having him bunt is as much a recipe for a double play (especially on a popped-up bunt) or a strikeout as having him swing away, except if he swings away he might get a hit where if he bunts he's essentially guaranteed to make at least one out.

I totally understand your reasoning, though.  If the spots in the order were reversed and it was Hillenbrand up with Overbay to follow, I might actually be tempted to pinch McDonald for Hillenbrand specifically to bunt. 

Chuck - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 10:12 AM EDT (#144610) #
...and you could legitimately prefer Hinske here as lefthanded and generally less susceptible to the DP.

While Shea is a GIDP threat from the moment he rolls out of bed in the morning, Rivera's cutter makes him a severely reverse-skewed pitcher, meaning that platoon advantages don't apply and that Hillenbrand is probably preferable to Hinske.

Rivera's three-year OPS split to LHB/RHB has been 485/585. And I don't think this is a recent phenomenon, at least if my memory of his annual Strat cards isn't sketchy.
Jevant - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 10:49 AM EDT (#144612) #
1) With Giambi holding Glaus on, that's a pretty big hole on the right side.  Also, with A-Rod on the line on 3rd base, there should be lots of room on that side as well.  Either way, I leave Overbay in.

2a) I trust Shea to put the ball in play.  Bat on the ball, etc.  He'll make contact.

2b) Here, I call for the Cat.  There's a better chance Cat would get on base, moving a runner to 3rd, even if he didn't come through with a hit (IE - working Rivera for a walk).  I'd also gamble on Cat coming through with a base hit.

3) Ryan pitches to Damon, and then I play it by ear. 

Newton - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 10:57 AM EDT (#144613) #

An important question to first ask yourself in the Overbay bunt scenario is whether the home team should play for a tie in this situation?  Does a bunt increase our chances of tying the game but decrease our chances of winning outright in that inning?

A quick comparison of available bullpen arms and current lineup configuration/bats off the bench would dictate that decision making and with the top of the Yanks order coming up I'd be inclined to go for the W. 

Have a great at bat Lyle.

 

 

SimonB - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:19 AM EDT (#144615) #
I think you have to weigh the relative strengths of the two team's bullpens, Newton. I stated that the Jays should go for the tie in this situation for the very same reason. Assuming the Jays' setup corps is as reliable as it was last year, Toronto's six pitchers behind Ryan will be better than - or equal to, if you prefer, because of New York's superior offense  - their Yankee counterparts. As the home team, then, there is no real reason to fear extra innings.

So with Mariano on the mound, you play for the tie. Because, well - good luck getting two more hits off of the best relief pitcher in baseball. We were lucky to get one; as much as you guys hate "small ball", it has a time and a place, and this is it.

zaptom - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:33 AM EDT (#144616) #
Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

Bunt! Rivera's 3 year splits at the Rogers Centre have Jay's batting .163 with 9K and 1BB. Getting two men on in a row is a blessing, and these guys must be advanced.

Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

No. Shea has good contact and power with the ball and that is the best way to drive in a run from 3rd either by a sac fly or a grounder. Hinske has more power, but a strikeout helps no one. Cat is a tempting choice because he can really work the count, but I'm sticking with Shea.

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?


No.

Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth?

Leave BJ in to face at least Damon and Jeter, he's rested so pitching 2 innings shouldn't be a problem. If Damon or Jeter reach scoring position, I'd know I have a full and fresh 'pen ready to take over. BJ has good stuff and should be lights out against the Yanks.
Anders - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:36 AM EDT (#144618) #
I think that Overbay bunting is a mistake - he's a good contactt hitter and he, as mentioned, doesnt bunt. Either way, if the situation ends up 2nd and 3rd, one out, with Shea up at bat, I let Shea hit, and If he cant get the job done, I bring in Cat to pinch hit for Molina, who I'm sure would get absolutely destroyed by Rivera.

Unless he has a problem with it, BJ is in for another inning, if problems arise I've got Speier and SS Loogy in the pen

Glevin - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:36 AM EDT (#144619) #

1) This is one situation where I would normally bunt, but not with Overbay.  I would really worry about a GDP, so I might try a hit and run.

2) I wouldn't PH for Hillenbrand because Rivera is actually tougher on LHB (.485 OPS last 3 years) than on RHB (.585) and it's not like the Jays have Delgado on the bench anyway. Even if Overbay got out, I still wouldn't PH.

3) Leaving Ryan in would depend on whether he had been pitching exclusively 1 inning all year.  Generally though, one inning closers seem to have a hard time when they pitch extra innings so I'd go with Ryan versus Damon and then let  my next best guy come in. (Speier or Fraser probably. Whoever is pitching better).

 

Little_Mac - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:44 AM EDT (#144625) #

Hello, all. Interesting topic, so here's my two cent.


Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

No bunt. You trust your best hitter in this situation. Let him swing away. However, I DO pitch-run McDonald for Glaus at first base. I might have to do some fancy manveouring in the 10th, but Wells + McDonald gives me a lot of possibilities for hit and runs, double-steal, etc. Glaus just screams easy double-play on the basepath. McDonald might break it up at second.

Hillenbrand's up. Rivera's pitching, 1 out, runners on 2nd and 3rd. You have Catalanotto, Hinske, Zaun and McDonald on your bench.  Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

Nope. Shea can get the job done. No one is a better option than Shea at that time.

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?

Nope. Shea is still hitting. However, I might call a hit and run if the count is 1 and 1. (I believe that Rivera is lousy at keeping runners on).

In the tenth, the Yanks have Damon, Jeter and A-Rod up, with Sheffield to follow. Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth? What is your pitching plan for the top of the tenth?

Ryan starts the inning. I basically say, it's your inning. If he tires out, it's SS LOOGY to the rescue (Though I really want Ryan in to face Matsui and Giambi).  I save Speier for Tomorrow's game.
Cristian - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:51 AM EDT (#144627) #
I think Craig stumbled onto the answer.  I'd pinch hit MacDonald for Overbay specifically to have MacDonald bunt.  By the way, why is it assumed that Overbay doesn't know how to bunt?  If I'm really the manager, I would have been running bunting drills with everyone all season for exactly these types of situations.  Shea stays up there to bring the runner in from third with one out.  If he fails, Bengie hits against Rivera because Bengie is *cue grumbles from the statheads* clutch. 
daryn - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 11:57 AM EDT (#144629) #
Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

No, I think Overbay fits the "professional hitter" mold. I let him work the count, if I can get a fastball count I sent the runners, and have Overbay hit in the whole on the right side, with luck I can get Wells home.

at least a grounder to first will move the runners ahead... looks like that is what happened...


Whatever you chose, the result is the same, the runners advance to second and third and Overbay is out. This leads to our next questions. Hillenbrand's up. Rivera's pitching, 1 out, runners on 2nd and 3rd. You have Catalanotto, Hinske, Zaun and McDonald on your bench.

Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

River is going to be murder on Shea... maybe Zaun, because he's a lefty and pretty fearless...
I think I would still go with Shea though...  get him to drive the ball through the infield...

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?


No, but I'd have Shea swing away..


Whatever you chose, your team scores a single run off Rivera and the game heads to extras. The water cooler in the Yankee dugout takes blows (with the feet) from Rivera and Johnson. In the tenth, the Yanks have Damon, Jeter and A-Rod up, with Sheffield to follow. Your final question is:

Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth?
Leave BJ Birdie in, unless he starts leaving the pitches up



SimonB - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 12:33 PM EDT (#144634) #
For the record, Overbay did have one sacrifice last season. It was the only one of his career, but it's still something to consider; he can do it in an absolute pinch. And I think trailing the Yankees by a run with Rivera on the mound qualifies as a pinch, especially with the division lead on the line.
Chuck - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 12:39 PM EDT (#144636) #
Overbay did have one sacrifice last season. It was the only one of his career, but it's still something to consider; he can do it in an absolute pinch

Yeah, but you don't know if he failed on his five other tries, popping out, hitting into a fielder's choice, etc. I don't know that this is the case, but his one successful bunt isn't evidence of anything.

And I would imagine that bunting one of Rivera's cutters under yours hands (if you're a lefty) can't be especially easy.
jjdynomite - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 12:50 PM EDT (#144638) #

1. Little_mac is the only one so far who wrote what I was thinking, also hinted by the unclear: "the result is the same, the runners advance to second and third and Overbay is out."  Which I take it to mean that Vernon and Troy may not necessarily still be the baserunners.  As such, I'd pinch run for Glaus with McDonald.  As for Overbay bunting, now that Glaus is being replaced, less of a likelihood of a slow dribbler leading to a double play.  And a double might bring both of them home.  Hit away, Overbay.

You could also try a double steal in this scenario.  Not.

2 & 3. I'd say leave Shea in, both situations.  There is nothing indicating that he has done poorly lately in RBI scenarios, Rivera notwithstanding.  Even if, he is the Jays' DH(itter), for a reason.

4. There is nothing indicating the number of >1 innings BJ has pitched.  If he's been getting rocked in those situations, I'd put in SS.  If, so far, neutral or success with >1, I'd leave BJ to face Damon and see what happens
.

Mike Green - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 01:03 PM EDT (#144642) #
I have amended the question to provide information concerning Ryan's prior appearances of more than an inning, as a couple of people have asked.
kinguy - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 03:07 PM EDT (#144663) #

Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

The first thing I'd do is send in a pinch runner for Glaus, then send the hit-and-run signal to Overbay.  McDonald could PR, then play 3rd in the 10th;  or Hinske could come in at 3rd.

Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?


Shea hits in either situation.  With runners on 2nd and 3rd, a sac fly ties the game.  With runners on 1st and 2nd, you'll need a hit down the line or into the gap, and there's no one on the bench that's a better option, keeping in mind that I don't want to empty the bench after sending in a PR, and the game could go well into extra innings, and I may want to bring Zaun in to catch.

Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth?

Since B.J. put the side down in order in the 9th, the assumption is that he didn't throw many pitches, so he should be good in the 10th.  If all three batters took him deep into the count and/or fouled off several pitches that ran the pitch count up, he'd pitch to at least Damon, but he'd stay in in the 10th until someone gets on base, then Chulk or Speier would relieve.

Dave Till - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 06:53 PM EDT (#144685) #
(I haven't seen any of the other answers as I write this.)

I'd have Overbay bunt at this point.

There would be no need to pinch-hit for Shea - the opposing manager will walk him to load the bases, if he's got any sense.

I'd bring in a new pitcher in the 10th. It's a long season - the Jays will be needing a lot of Ryan later on. If it were a more crucial game, I'd probably leave him in.

Dave Till - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 06:56 PM EDT (#144686) #
(Posting again after reading comments.)

This was fun - a chance to second-guess myself.

I didn't realize that Overbay can't bunt - that obviously affects things. If he fails to sacrifice, I'd leave Shea in to hit.

Michael - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 08:23 PM EDT (#144687) #
Do you call for a bunt from Overbay? Do you make any other moves?

No bunt.  I check my spreadsheets and automatic WPA calculator for what outcomes are likely.

Do you pinch-hit for Shea?

No.  Shea is as good as anyone left on the bench.

Would the answer have been different if Overbay had popped up (either a bunt or swinging away), leaving runners at 1st and 2nd, rather than 2nd and 3rd?


No.

Who comes out to pitch for the top of the tenth?
Do you leave Ryan in there, or call for somebody else? What is your pitching plan for the top of the tenth?

Ryan stays.  That's why he's paid the big bucks.
Craig B - Friday, April 07 2006 @ 10:41 PM EDT (#144688) #
I check my spreadsheets and automatic WPA calculator for what outcomes are likely.

*bursts into tears*
Mike Green - Monday, April 10 2006 @ 11:39 AM EDT (#144821) #

My answers:

1.   I don't bunt with Overbay, but I do tell him that he can if he wants to; this is not an occasion for a telegraphed bunt.

2.   Hillenbrand hits with runners on 2nd and 3rd.  His strength, putting bat on ball, is a real asset, and his weakness, the propensity to hit into DPs, is not an issue.  I'd pinch hit with Catalanotto with runners on 1st and 2nd, notwithstanding Rivera's cutter.

3.   Ryan starts the 10th, and continues for the rest of the inning as long as there is no sign of tiring.  I want him to go 2 innings on a semi-frequent basis.

Craig B - Monday, April 10 2006 @ 12:07 PM EDT (#144825) #

Mike, if the runners were on 1st and 2nd and Cat popped out, would you hit with Molina or pinch-hit Hinske or Zaun?

Mike Green - Monday, April 10 2006 @ 12:17 PM EDT (#144826) #
I'd let Molina hit. With Rivera pitching, and Hinske relatively fresh off the DL, I wouldn't pinch-hit for Molina with him in this situation.  As for Zaun, again given Rivera's stuff and the natural disadvantage that pinch-hitters have, Molina's probably a better bet.  I probably would feel differently about it if there was 1 out because of Molina's ability to hit into DPs at will.
Craig B - Wednesday, April 12 2006 @ 01:59 PM EDT (#145004) #

OK Mike, I had another thought about this.  By the way, I would have Zaun hit for Molina in that situation above (actually, I said earlier I was going to hold back Cat to hit for Molina, so I would have done that, but anyway...)

But instead let's run a different way with your scenario.  Let's say that, like before, the runners were on 1st and 2nd, and you PH with Catalanotto, and instead of a popout Cat draws a walk.  Now you have the bases loaded, one out, and Molina at the plate.  Would you still let Molina hit?  Or would you PH Hinske or Zaun?

You Be the Manager-Big Game, Small Ball, Extra Fun | 33 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.