Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
They're never too far
away from men who made the grade
out in a world of their own
They'll never come down
until the battle's lost or made

Standings as of June 13th, 2005

1. Baltimore    36-26 .581         (6- 7 2WK)
2. Boston       33-29 .532  3.0 GB (6- 7 2WK)
3. Toronto      31-32 .492  5.5 GB (4- 9 2WK)
4. New York     30-32 .484  6.0 GB (3- 9 2WK)
5. Tampa Bay    21-42 .333 15.5 GB (2-10 2WK)
A horrible week for the division, as all 5 teams played below .500 ball. Does anybody want to win this division? Wasn't this supposed to be the toughest division in baseball? Right now the division has a .484 winning percentage. Ouch! Somebody has to win this thing, though. But who will it be? According to Tradesports.com, the percentage likelihood of each team winning the division is roughly:

Percentage Chance of Winning the Division

Boston:    36% (16% of winning AL Pennant)
New York:  33% (20% of winning AL Pennant)
Baltimore: 27% ( 9% of winning AL Pennant)
Toronto:    4% ( 1% of winning AL Pennant)
Tampa Bay:  0% ( 0% of winning AL Pennant)
Those Toronto odds look very low, while the Tampa Bay ones are far too optimistic. There are no odds listed for who is going to win the Wild Card, but there's a decent chance the WC winner will come from the AL East.

With 4 teams all with a reasonable shot at making the playoffs, it will be interesting to see what kind of moves each will make as we reach the trading deadline. By looking at the positions where each team has struggled over the season, we can get a sense of where they might try to improve.

Baltimore - 325 Runs Scored, 285 Runs Allowed

Eli Marrero should be a decent placeholder until Javy Lopez comes back. The regular with the lowest OPS is Raffy with a .255/.335/.410 line. Would they really bring someone new in and bench Palmeiro during a pennant race? I suppose anything is possible.

The rotation has been surprisingly effective this year, with Bedard and Chen pitching a surprising number of quality innings. The weakest starter so far this year has been Daniel Cabrera, but 62 walks in 67 1/3 innings is certainly impressive. The 33 walks, however, are not.

The pen has been a source of strength for the O's, with B.J. Ryan notching 16 saves and a 1.99 ERA. The Orioles may want to avoid picking up anyone named Steve, though, as both Reed and Kline have struggled this year.

Boston - 333 Runs Scored, 317 Runs Allowed

No real holes in the lineup to speak of, as they're scoring a pile of runs. Edgar Renteria is "only" hitting .265/.312/.380, but it's not as if they'd go out and get another shortstop. Millar is slugging .381, so it's possible the Red Sox might be interested in another 1B/DH type. But these days, who isn't?

On the pitching side, they've got a few more problems. Clement has been terrific and Arroyo and Wakfield have been solid. David Wells has not been spectacular, giving up 9 homeruns in 10 starts. His 30/4 K/BB ratio is Radkeesque, but 4.5 K/9 isn't anything to write hom about.

The bullpen is an area that could use some upgrades. Timlin and Myers have been spectacular, but Mantei and Foulke both have ERAs near 6. Neither one of them has a K/BB ratio above 2:1 and Foulke has given up 6 homeruns in 28 innings.

New York - 316 Runs Scored, 313 Runs Allowed

They look like a lower scoring version of the Red Sox this season, which is why they're likely to make some moves soon. Hitting only .239 with 3 homeruns, it may be the end of the line for Bernie Williams. It was a hell of a run, though. Tony Womack has turned back into a pumpkin as both his slugging and his on-base percentages are below .300. They could also use a DH. This is a team with a lot of holes which is being propped up by A-Rod's monster year.

Kevin Brown's peripherals look decent (though he could use a few more strikeouts), but his results have been doubleplusungood, as he has a 4-6 record with a 5.43 ERA. Jaret Wright has a 9.15 ERA in 4 starts. Johnson, Pavano, and Mussina have all been good, but not outstanding.

New York's third-best reliever this season has been Tanyon Sturtze. Rivera and Gordon have been excellent, though Gordon's ERA is better than his peripherals. Paul Quantrill looks done, with only 9 strikeouts (to 5 walks and 5 homeruns) in 25 1/3 innings. Stanton and Karsay both have ERAs at or over 6.

Toronto - 285 Runs Scored, 270 Runs Allowed

Will Toronto be a buyer or a seller? It's tough to say right now - I think we'll have to give it another couple of weeks. Orlando Hudson has been strugling with the bat, which is why I would be against trading him now - why sell low? Russ Adams is putting up rookie like numbers, but a .396 slugging against a .229 batting average is pretty good. What will he be slugging if he can get the average up to .270?

Pitching? I think we've used up enough bits on this site discussing Ted Lilly, so I won't do so any further.

Is it too early for itoldyousos on Schoeneweis? Then again, I was wrong about a pile of stuff this off-season as well.

Question of the day: Who will AL East teams trade for and what will they send in return? Be specific as possible, such as Larry Andersen to Boston for Jeff Bagwell.

It's sunny and you're rich! | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Stellers Jay - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:17 PM EDT (#119513) #
Alright, I'll take the first swing. I'll probably hit this as hard as Huckaby usually does, but I think it makes a lot of sense for both teams.

Toronto trades Hillenbrand back to Boston for Kelly Shoppach and a PTBNL. Ricciardi might need to pick up some of the cash to do it. Shoppach is tearing up the IL to the tune of .279/.392/.571 He'd be an instant upgrade at catcher for Toronto and he'd be insurance in case Quiroz never gets back to where he was projected to be. It also frees up a permanent spot for Aaron Hill as it looks like he is ready to stay in the big leagues. He can DH 50% of the time and spell Koskie, Adams, and Hinske a day a week each. Boston could use Hillenbrand at 1st and 3rd to get more production out of those spots. Shoppach is blocked by Varitek and Mirabelli, and isn't of long term use to Boston.

I really like this move and think it probably makes way too much sense in my head for it to really happen.
Ducey - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:30 PM EDT (#119514) #
I don't the Jays are going to go for it but I think JP is going to try to retool for 2006. He needs a #2 starter and I think he will trade for Barry Zito. He will send Purcey, ODog and Ryan Roberts to the A's for him. He will also unload Hillenbrand, Hinske, Lilly, Cat, SS Loogy, and Towers to anyone who will take them.

Baltimore could be in the running for Zito as well.

I'll bet Jason Schmidt will go to the Red Sox and Todd Helton winds up a Yankee. Tampa Bay will do nothing but begin contemplating their future without Lou Pinella.
Pistol - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:32 PM EDT (#119515) #
I would think that Shoppach would get more in return than Hillenbrand, or if it didn't I don't think the Sox would make the move.
dp - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:51 PM EDT (#119516) #
I agree, Shoppach will take a lot more than Shea. N/s how Shea's history w/Theo plays into Boston's willingness to acquire him. Shea to the Mets makes the most sense, though I think the Mets giving Vic Diaz a glove and sticking him at 1B would be better. Minaya loves guys who swing the bat, and showed a willingness to make impact prospect for vet deals with Montreal. The problem is the Mets have mostly pitching depth, which is good for them, but makes them a poor trade partner for the Jays. Seo or Heilman plus a hitting prospect would likely get it done- the Mets have a 3B prospect who has come on strong lately, irrelevant b/c of Wright.
Stellers Jay - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:52 PM EDT (#119517) #
Varitek is signed for 4 years and Mirabelli's got another year left on his deal. Shoppach is 25 and is putting together a good year, it seems like a good time for Boston to sell high on him because they have no use for him long term. It may be that they could fetch more than Hillenbrand for him but barring an injury to one of the above I don't think there's any way Shoppach is still with Boston at the end of the year.
Smaj - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:56 PM EDT (#119518) #
I am intrigued by the Shoppach deal...catching depth is a great asset & Quiroz is a question mark right now. Huckaby is too painful to watch at the dish.

I will throw a knuckleball for everyone to rip at:

Wells,Lilly,Speier,Cat& Josh Banks to Texas for Texeira,Mench & PTBNL. Lilly is undesirable but Texas is playing for now & could use a starter (gamble he returns to form). They need bullpen help & Speier is recovering from a poor start & was outstanding in the 2nd half last year. Cat is a DH or a part time starter in a lineup still filled with power. Wells is the apple of Texas' eye being an Arlington Texas resident. Rangers need a CF badly & Silver Slugging / Gold Glovers are very rare commodities indeed. Its a PR win for the Rangers. Texas has Adrian Gonzalez waiting in the minors (former MLB Draft 1st overall with the Marlins).
Jays need Power & Texeira provides it plus plays 1st base. Jays have the cash to lock him up long term. Mench is a power hitting LF who could play RF if needed. Rios moves to CF for the time being.

Now the key is to find a taker for Hinske (How about Hinske, Gross, Jason Arnold, Marcum for Aubrey Huff)?

Jays Lineup:

Zaun
Texeira
Hudson
Koskie
Adams
Reed Johnson (Huff?)
Rios
Mench
Hill-DH

Rangers Lineup:

Barrajas
Gonzalez (or Cat)
Soriano
Blaylock
Young
Delucci
Wells
Hidalgo
Nix (DH or Cat)
Stellers Jay - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 03:57 PM EDT (#119519) #
Hillenbrand to the Dodgers makes a lot of sense too. They are looking for a 3B and he could also platoon with Choi at first. LA's got lots of prospects and the GM's used to work together. How about Hillenbrand for Navarro? Toronto could use a catcher.
Ben - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 04:18 PM EDT (#119520) #
I think Hillenbrand is being grossly overvalued at the moment. I dont think at all that he's worth a premiere catching prospect. He's having a relatively decent year but I dont think there is any way he will bring Shoppach or Navarro. Shoppach will probably be traded but for pitching help as Epstein has publicly said that things need to be turned around. The only way I can see the Jays getting Shoppach is a by three team trade in which someone besides Shea is dealt. What would seem to make sense to me would be a Oakland/Toronto/Boston deal involving Zito. Also Navarro is not going anywhere as Jason Phillips and Paul Bako arent exactly long term solutions. Just my two cents.
Mike Green - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 04:23 PM EDT (#119521) #
Tampa Bay are clearly sellers, but what to sell? On offence, they've got Crawford, Baldelli, Huff, now Taylor, Lugo, Cantu, Green, Lee, Hall with Gathright, Gomes and Upton doing well in Triple A and Delmon Young tearing up double A. And they've got very, very little pitching.

So, who do you keep? If it were me, Gathright, Crawford and Young would be my outfield by mid-06, Upton, Lugo, Cantu and Gomes/Huff (sharing 1B/DH duties) would be by my infield.

Baldelli has started extended spring training after his knee injury, and is expected to be back around the All-Star break. I doubt that the Rays can make reasonable decisions about their outfield or get full value until after the trading deadline this year. So, it's Travis Lee on the block, and that aint much.
Gitz - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 04:38 PM EDT (#119523) #
Erm. It's a good thought, but Teixeira isn't going anywhere for at least his arbitration years (thru 2008). I wouldn't trade him for Wells, Lilly, Adams, Bush, and any other combo you could come up with.
Gitz - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 04:45 PM EDT (#119524) #
Edgar Renteria is "only" hitting .265/.312/.380, but it's not as if they'd go out and get another shortstop.

Why the quotes? Renteria's having a bad year, and it's not as if anybody should be surprised; he's being paid millions for one millions-worth season (2003), but he hasn't been all that special the rest of his career. Question: who's the more useless $10 million player, Jason Kendall or Renteria?

Mike Green - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 05:08 PM EDT (#119525) #
Well, two. He was pretty much an equivalent hitter to Jeter in 2002 and 2003, and, of course, a much better fielder.

I'd have said that he was a gamble going into 2005. It wouldn't surprise me at all if he's at .280/.360/.440 by the the end of the season, notwithstanding his slow start.
Ben - Monday, June 13 2005 @ 05:19 PM EDT (#119527) #
Question: who's the more useless $10 million player, Jason Kendall or Renteria?

Pre injury or right now? I gotta go with Kendall, theyre both doing horrible and are way below projections but the thing that really gets me is that people are 50 for 56 against him. He is having no effect at all stopping the running game. Although I do have to say Renteria is also having a godawful year with the glove as well.
It's sunny and you're rich! | 13 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.