Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine Batter's Box Interactive Magazine
The college baseball season is a couple months old, so as many students prepare to take midterm exams we'll take a look at how the top baseball prospects are grading out on the field so far.

Below are a baker's dozen of the top hitting and pitching prospects in college baseball who are eligible for this year's draft, listed alphabetically among pitchers and hitters.

Note - these are unadjusted stats. Adjustments for park and competition, however, have been made in the '04 Burley Rankings'. Stats are through March 27th.

Pitchers:

Luke Hochavar, RHP, Tennessee
6'5', 205 lbs, 9/15/83
04 Burley Ranking - 215
Year	Inn	ERA	K/9	BB/9	HR/9
2005	51.0	1.76   10.6	1.9	0.2
2004	63.0	2.86	8.6	3.3	1.0
2003	77.2	4.64	8.5	2.8	1.0
Mike Pelfrey, RHP, Wichita St
6'7", 215 lbs, 1/14/84
04 Burley Ranking - 27
Year	Inn	ERA	K/9	BB/9	HR/9
2005	 52.0	1.73	9.2	2.3	0.3
2004	115.1	2.18	9.8	1.9	0.2
2003	104.2	2.49	8.5	1.3	0.8
Wade Townsend, RHP, Rice
6'4", 225 lbs, RHP, 2/22/83
04 Burley Ranking - 4
Year	Inn	ERA	K/9	BB/9	HR/9
2004	120.1	1.80	11.1	3.4	0.4
2003	118.2	2.20	12.5	3.5	0.2
2002	 51.1	2.28	 9.0	3.9	0.7

Wade Townsend was drafted by the Orioles 8th overall last year, but ended up returning to Rice to finish his degree, but not playing for the Owls. Because he returned to school he was no longer eligible to sign with the O's and is returning to the draft this year.

Hitters:

Ryan Braun, 3b/SS, Miami FL
6'2", 205 lbs
Bats: R - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 132

Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	105	0.457	0.519	0.848
2004	155	0.335	0.439	0.606
2003	242	0.364	0.446	0.665
Jeff Clement, C, USC
6'1", 205 lbs, 8/21/83
Bats: L - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 339

Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 73	0.342	0.505	0.658
2004	198	0.293	0.416	0.515
2003	208	0.298	0.402	0.649
Stephen Head, 1B, Mississippi
6'2", 220 lbs, 1/13/84
Hits: L – Throws: L
04 Burley Ranking - 60
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 95	0.347	0.431	0.705
2004	228	0.346	0.419	0.583
2003	208	0.337	0.385	0.490

Head also is a fairly accomplished pitcher, although most agree that his future as a hitter is higher than his future as a pitcher.

Alex Gordon, 3B, Nebraska
6'1", 205 lbs, 2/10/84
Hits: L – Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 5
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 84	0.429	0.579	0.905
2004	211	0.365	0.493	0.754
2003	216	0.319	0.426	0.495

No, that's not a misprint.

Tyler Greene, SS, Georgia Tech
6'2", 188 lbs, 8/17/83
Bats: R - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 785
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	105	0.343	0.425	0.581
2004	256	0.273	0.371	0.434
2003	228	0.316	0.391	0.474
Jed Lowrie, 2B, Stanford
6'0", 180 lbs, 4/17/84
Hits: R – Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 1
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 84	0.310	0.392	0.655
2004	233	0.399	0.505	0.734
2003	212	0.292	0.349	0.349
John Mayberry, 1b/of, Stanford
6'5", 230 lbs, 12/21/83
Bats: R - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 91
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 87	0.333	0.426	0.529
2004	216	0.333	0.419	0.625
2003	194	0.299	0.344	0.454
Jeremy Slayden, OF, Georgia Tech
6'0", 196 lbs
Bats: L - Throws: R

Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005    101     0.396   0.492   0.713
2004	35	0.286	0.366	0.400
2003	218	0.294	0.394	0.523
2002	256	0.348	0.442	0.625

Slayden started the first nine games of the 2004 season before undergoing surgery on his right shoulder.

Troy Tulowitzki, SS, Long Beach St
6'3", 200 lbs, 10/10/84
Bats: R - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 530
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 27	0.407	0.484	0.519
2004	230	0.317	0.410	0.491
2003	196	0.270	0.307	0.408
Ryan Zimmerman, 3b, Virginia
6'3", 210 lbs
Bats: R - Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 558
Year	ABs	Ave	Obp	Slg
2005	 95	0.389	0.450	0.600
2004	249	0.361	0.395	0.454
2003	221	0.308	0.340	0.376

The Blue Jays pick 6th in the first round. Baseball America's initial mock draft had high schoolers Justin Upton and Cameron Maybin going 1-2, followed by Gordon, Hochavar, and Pelfrey. Based on their performances so far this year it doesn't look like their stock has dropped at all.

I've been on the Stephen Head bandwagon for awhile now, and it looks like he's continuing to improve. But other players are showing improvements as well, especially in the power department, namely Braun, Clement, Greene, Slayden and Zimmerman.

And in the 'you can never have too much pitching' camp Wade Townsend has to be a consideration as he was one of the top college pitchers last year in a deep draft for starters.

The wild cards in the draft are the Boras clients. Will Weaver and Drew re-enter the draft? Will teams pass on the top pitchers because they're associated with Boras?

With the pursestrings loosened in Toronto this won't be a factor as much as it might have been in the past, or at least that's what Ricciardi told Bauxites in an interview earlier this year:

Given the recent cash infusion from ownership, would the Jays be open to giving a player a major-league deal? Would they be willing to select a Scott Boras client? “We have to be open to that this year. It doesn’t mean we’re going to do it, but we have to be open-minded to everything. We’re not going to shy away from anything, but we’re not going to be held captive by it.”

So by the time the draft rolls around in a couple months the Jays should have a quality pool of players to choose from.

Midterm Progress Report | 16 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.
Cristian - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 09:58 AM EST (#108265) #
Any idea if the teams drafting 1 to 5 are likely to snatch up a Drew or a Weaver?
Gerry - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 10:12 AM EST (#108269) #
The Jays appear to highly value performance in the Cape Cod league. Were any of these potential picks outstanding on the cape last year?
Mike Green - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 10:24 AM EST (#108270) #
Here was BA's take on the 2004 Cape season. Head and Greene shone.
Pistol - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 11:12 AM EST (#108278) #
"Any idea if the teams drafting 1 to 5 are likely to snatch up a Drew or a Weaver?"

Seattle took Matt Tuiasosopo in the third round last year and gave him a $2.3 million signing bonus, so it's possible they'd be willing to take Drew or Weaver.

The Diamondbacks took Drew this past draft and it wouldn't seem to make sense to draft one of Drew or Weaver #1 overall if they couldn't sign Drew this year.

KC and Milwaukee passed on both last year, and Washington/Montreal didn't draft Drew (Weaver was taken a pick before their pick) so I wouldn't expect any of those three teams to take either Drew or Weaver should they re-enter the draft.
Thomas - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 11:19 AM EST (#108281) #
Townshend's a name that really intrigued me last year.

Does anyone know how he plans to stay in baseball shape over the year since he's not playing with the Rice Owls?
Pistol - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 11:25 AM EST (#108284) #
Here's a BA story from a couple months ago on Townsend:

http://www.baseballamerica.com/today/college/050119manuel.html
Max Parkinson - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 11:28 AM EST (#108285) #
Alex Gordon, 3B, Nebraska
6'1", 205 lbs, 2/10/84
Hits: L – Throws: R
04 Burley Ranking - 5

No, that's not a misprint.



Far be it from me to rip on Alex Gordon - he'll be no lower than the 2nd pick this year, I'm sure - but here is where translating NCAA stats (especially midseason) takes a little nuance.

The Huskers have played about 25 games this year. Exactly 3 of them have been against good teams. 2 against Rice, and 1 against USC West, all in the Round Rock tournament.

In these 3 games, Gordon is hitting .200/.333/.500. 2-10, 2 walks and a bomb. Note that the bomb was mad clutch, a 3-run go-ahead shot against Rice in the 8th.

Sample size, I know. The point is, when evaluating these hitters, understand what they did in conference vs. out of conference, and understand what their out of conference schedule is like.

By year end, Gordon will still be the best hitter in college. But I'd be absolutely amazed if he's slugging near 1.000 after facing Texas, Baylor, Okla St. and the rest of the Big XII (why can't they say 12?, is it arrogance?)
Max Parkinson - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 12:15 PM EST (#108293) #
One other thing that should be considered in the draft (particularly with college players) is the Boras factor.

There are a number of teams that simply will not deal with Scott Boras - I'm not sure where the Jays stand on this - and therefore the actual drafting order may not be based on talent.

This year my be especially bad, as 10 of the top 20 or so college players are represented by Boras - including the top 3 pitchers available, Pelfrey, Hoechevar and Weaver (if he's not signed). As well, the 3 real hard throwers (Hansen, McCormick and Neighbourgall - who's shown flashes of brilliance as well as moments of disaster so far this year).

If enough teams stick to a "No Boras" philosophy, the first round could get mighty wierd.
Max Parkinson - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 03:24 PM EST (#108343) #
Oh, so Pistol already said all that. My bad.
robertdudek - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 05:32 PM EST (#108401) #
Both Jered Weaver and Stephen Drew have cost themsleves a lot of development time, and most probably a substantial amount of cash. Holding out for an extra mill or two doesn't make sense for a 21 year old if it means 12 months of lost time. Hopefully college stars will start to realise this and change their negotiating strategies accordingly.

Look at what happened to JD Drew: his holdout meant that he reached arbitration and free agency a year later. These delays more than offset the extra cash he got out of St. Louis as compared to what Philly would have offered.
Max Parkinson - Thursday, March 31 2005 @ 05:49 PM EST (#108409) #
Robert, I couldn't agree more.

However, players who go with Boras have to know that this has happened before (cf. Varitek, Hill, Drew), and the good ones still flock to him in droves.
Mike Green - Tuesday, April 05 2005 @ 11:57 AM EDT (#109246) #
Ryan Zimmerman went 11-14 off a fine UNC staff this past weekend. He apparently has Gold Glove quality defence at third, and is emerging as a fine overall hitter, albeit at a lower level than Alex Gordon. Here's an interesting comment on him from yesterday's BA chat wrap.
costanza - Tuesday, April 05 2005 @ 12:43 PM EDT (#109261) #
Look at what happened to JD Drew: his holdout meant that he reached arbitration and free agency a year later.

I'm not sure I'd agree. Drew did make the majors as a callup in '98, stuck in the majors in '99, and became a free agent six years after being re-drafted.

Drafted immediately after Drew in '97, Troy Glaus only beat Drew to the majors by a few weeks, and both became free agents this off-season (I think). Was there a perception that Drew would've made the majors in '97 if he'd signed with the Phillies?

Going back into the draft might not be the best option for most players, but I don't know if it hurt Drew at all. On the contrary, I suspect that Boras uses J.D. as an example of how going back into the draft can help the client, and that he has some justification for doing so.

rtcaino - Friday, April 08 2005 @ 05:03 AM EDT (#109943) #
After all the agony of the 04 season, it appears that the silver lining is rearing is "head".
As it stands, the Jay's system is quite above average, especially in the arms department. However, it has been well pointed out that we lack bats. Well 94 some odd losses and it looks like we may be able to address the issue.

How does Stephen Head compare to Justin Morneau? How similar are they in terms of power vs. patience? Who has the higher ceiling?


Pistol - Friday, April 08 2005 @ 09:05 AM EDT (#109946) #
I think a decent comparison for Head would be Michael Aubrey who the Indians took a couple years ago.
Pistol - Friday, April 08 2005 @ 01:39 PM EDT (#109964) #
Alex Gordon of Nebraska is playing #1 ranked Texas this weekend and it looks like the games will be on ESPN2 if anyone is interested in watching.
Midterm Progress Report | 16 comments | Create New Account
The following comments are owned by whomever posted them. This site is not responsible for what they say.