Tango, this is great. Thanks for compiling the information and presenting it in digestible format.

A comparison between "the fan consensus" and "the metric consensus" might result in even closer results, although the veteran bias in the fan's selections is undoubtedly an important factor in the disparity.

It's funny. I always thought of Jeter as a centerfielder, but it's hard to argue with the fans who see him day in and day out.

Where is A-Rod?? Not enough votes?

Right, not enough Ranger fans voted. Of those who did, they really love him.

Darn, I would have loved to see where Sparky placed on the chart.