In yesterday's thread about the greatest Jay of all time, greenfrog described Roy Halladay as the most "all-around enjoyable Blue Jay to watch."
Magpie suggested Tony Castillo (as well as Jesse Barfield, Tom Henke, and Paul Molitor). He also thought this might be a worthy thread.
I agree.
My personal nominees, in addition to the above, are Shaun Marcum and Orlando Hudson.
https://www.battersbox.ca/article.php?story=20110110021036699