This is a list of the top 40 MLB pitchers calculated by DIPS runs below replacement. I use the "Quick DIPS" ERA (the only one I can calculate using Doug Steele's stats which don't include IBB) but it's good enough. These are NOT park-adjusted, and are based on July 23 numbers. I'm going to try to post park-adjusted numbers later, in this thread. Replacement level is a 5.50 DIPS ERA, about equivalent to 5.8 runs allowed per game.
For entertainment purposes only. Not to be taken internally.
schmidt,jason 40.64
brown,kevin 37.21
prior,mark 36.93
martinez,pedro 36.86
mussina,mike 33.64
hudson,tim 33.49
loaiza,esteban 33.20
millwood,kevin 30.92
halladay,roy 30.73
clemens,roger 29.67
batista,miguel 28.77
mulder,mark 28.57
zambrano,carlos 27.04
williams,woody 26.55
redman,mark 26.03
ponson,sidney 25.98
wood,kerry 25.93
vazquez,javier 25.31
willis,dontrell 24.39
pineiro,joel 23.55
webb,brandon 23.54
gagne,eric 23.43
schilling,curt 23.38
seo,jae_weong 23.32
nomo,hideo 23.23
wolf,randy 22.85
eaton,adam 22.73
suppan,jeff 22.70
penny,brad 22.48
pettitte,andy 22.29
pavano,carl 21.63
miller,wade 21.46
colon,bartolo 21.39
wells,david 20.54
myers,brett 20.53
santana,johan 20.53
donnelly,brenda 20.46
smoltz,john 20.11
morris,matt 19.89
sabathia,c.c. 19.79
Kelvim Escobar is 41st at 19.71, Cory Lidle is 65th at 15.02.
https://www.battersbox.ca/article.php?story=20030725105140999